Biden has a big climate win at home. Global success still depends on China.
The
White House plans to push partners and reboot talks with Beijing as it
mulls replacing a Trump appointee at the World Bank, David Malpass
September 23, 2022 at 2:21 p.m. EDT
President Biden is entering a crucial season of global climate talks boosted by the legislative victory of the Inflation Reduction Act,
betting he can undercut China’s arguments that the United States is a
less reliable negotiating partner because its policies depend on who is
in power in Washington.
The
new push comes as a freeze in climate talks between China and the
United States, tensions over who should pay for the damage caused by
global warming and an energy crisis and war in Europe
have weighed on the prospects for the gathering in the Egyptian resort
city of Sharm el-Sheikh. On Friday, Europe’s top climate negotiator said
that his fears were diminishing that a United Nations climate
conference in Egypt in November would be a “train crash,” given passage of the new climate law and recent moves by other global negotiators.
The
plan for talks between the United States and China, unveiled with
fanfare during the Glasgow climate summit last year, aimed to tackle a
broad range of planet-warming emissions. But the negotiations between
Washington and Beijing — the world’s most important climate dialogue —
have been frozen since House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) infuriated
Chinese officials by visiting Taiwan last month.
“There’s
zero, there’s no communication. They suspended it. I think it’s a
tragic loss. It’s just a sad turn of events,” Biden’s special climate
envoy, former secretary of state John F. Kerry, said in an interview.
“It’s really a major lost opportunity globally for us to get together.”
Kerry and his Chinese counterpart, Xie Zhenhua, surprised climate negotiators last year in Glasgow
when they pledged to work together — a commitment both nations framed
as a breakthrough. Kerry said the talks were making progress before
Beijing suspended them to protest Pelosi’s visit.
The
administration is also considering trying to replace the leader of the
World Bank, a Trump administration appointee, in a bid to have the
international finance institution focus more on climate change. Senior
Biden aides have discussed pushing for the ouster of David Malpass, the
World Bank president, for more than a year.
Those
conversations were reignited this week after Malpass sparked an
international uproar by refusing to say at a panel sponsored by the New
York Times that climate change was caused by human behavior, according
to two people familiar with the matter who spoke on the condition of
anonymity to talk about internal White House discussions. Raj Shah,
president of the Rockefeller Foundation, is widely seen as a likely
candidate for the post, these individuals said, as is Ngozi
Okonjo-Iweala, who leads the World Trade Organization.
Axios first reported Friday that the White House is considering ousting Malpass.
White
House officials are also weighing whether Biden can attend the U.N.
climate conference, known as COP27, to signal his commitment to global
efforts to reduce emissions. The two weeks of talks begin on Nov. 6, two
days before the U.S. midterm elections, and Biden will attend a Group
of 20 summit in Indonesia on Nov. 15 and 16.
“I
know that it’s very high on the agenda in the White House in terms of
their hopes,” Kerry said. “I know he wants to go, and I think it would
be helpful if he does go. It’s always helpful to have the president of
the United States helping you do your job.”
Biden’s trip could also serve as a fix-it mission to restore Sino-American climate negotiations, which have fallen apart.
The
United States and China had spent months working to develop working
groups before the negotiations halted, Kerry said, adding that the two
sides were discussing Chinese efforts to reduce methane emissions and
coal burning, as well as to improve the enforcement of existing Chinese
anti-deforestation legislation.
“We
had a group of people who were really expert and ready to roll,” Kerry
said. He said he had already met with Chinese counterparts this year in
Davos, Berlin and Stockholm, and that they had planned to meet for
“several days” ahead of the U.N. conference to try to come up with
concrete pledges.
All that now appears off the table, Kerry said.
“It’s
literally hanging there in limbo. They did suspend it, they didn’t
terminate it, but there’s no sign that that suspension will lift,” he
said. He said he would not speculate about whether the change reflected a
broader, go-it-alone shift in China’s climate strategy or something
more short term and less fundamental.
But
Europe’s top climate negotiator, Frans Timmermans, said that the nearly
$370 billion in U.S. climate investments from the new law would give a
push to China even in the absence of a direct dialogue with Washington.
“The
fact that the U.S. is now also walking the walk and not just talking
the talk has a huge impact on many,” Timmermans said in an interview.
“Whenever
we talk to the Chinese it’s the same: ‘Yes, okay, we know we need to do
more, but whatever we announce we actually do. [Americans] say the
right things but they haven’t really done anything’” Timmermans said.
“They can’t do that anymore, and I think that’s probably the most
important political element right now.”
He
said that heading into a visit this week to New York and Washington,
“my ambition level was what can we do to avoid a train crash in Sharm
el-Sheikh.” Now, he said, he was more confident that some of the
heaviest global emitters will increase their ambitions rather than
stepping back from commitments they made a year ago.
Other top international energy and climate officials said that China’s actions to address its emissions, which the Rhodium Group estimates accounts for more than a quarter of the world’s annual carbon output, will play a decisive role in global efforts to fight climate change.
“In
the absence of having cooperation with China on the climate change
front, we have no chance whatsoever to reach our climate change goals,”
said Fatih Birol, the executive director of the International Energy
Agency, in an interview. “I understand there are major political
hurdles, but I am still for having, on the climate, an open channel in
terms of cooperation between the two largest economies, China and the
United States.”
Birol
said that Kerry’s personal relationship with China’s chief climate
negotiator, Xie Zhenhua, might be crucial in reviving the conversation.
“The personal mutual trust may help to get this though,” Birol said.
For
all the international goodwill created by the climate legislation,
policymakers still face daunting challenges as they enter the final
phase of their discussions ahead of the meeting in Egypt. More than
1,500 people died in floods that Pakistan’s leaders called “apocalyptic.” Europe had the hottest summer in recorded history. Wildfires have covered most of the Lower 48 states with an “expansive area of light smoke,” the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration said.
And
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has sparked an energy crisis in Europe
that is forcing many countries there to burn more fossil fuels in the
short run to avoid freezing their citizens this winter. Paradoxically,
that means Europe is buying oil and gas from the same developing nations
they have been urging to reduce their own emissions.
Catherine
McKenna, a former Canadian environment minister, told a panel at
Columbia University this week that liquefied natural gas and crude oil
was going from nations such as Algeria, Nigeria and Egypt to Europe.
“Energy developed in Africa is being diverted to prevent energy poverty in Europe,” she said.
For some Biden administration officials, the fight against climate change is personal.
“I
was born the first time we hit 350 parts per million,” said Ali Zaidi,
Biden’s national climate adviser, who was born in Karachi. Before his
parents moved to the United States, his mother had worked as a doctor in
a public hospital that was overloaded in normal periods, Zaidi said.
One of his cousins trained at Johns Hopkins University for work in
public health in Pakistan.
“Karachi
is relatively unperturbed. But areas outside are in dire, dire straits.
It’s staggering,” he said. “People hear one third, but people don’t
realize that’s tens of millions of people.”
Zaidi said “For me, code red for humanity — it’s here.”
This
year’s U.N. climate talks come at a moment of transition within the
administration. Zaidi just replaced Biden’s first climate adviser, Gina
McCarthy, who stepped down last week.
John D. Podesta, a veteran Democratic policymaker, became a senior
adviser to oversee how to distribute the new law’s climate funding.
“I
intend to work with the teams here at the White House and the cabinet
and their people to ensure that the promises that are contained in this
bill to create that cycle of innovation actually occurs,” Podesta said
in an interview.
White
House officials acknowledge that Kerry has been dogged by persistent
rumors he plans to resign after the talks in Egypt — raising additional
questions about the future of the relationship with China. In an
interview, he said he had not yet made plans.
“I’m full speed ahead,” Kerry said. “Honestly, I’ve not made any decisions on where things are going, where I’m going.”
Kerry
said that he thought the Inflation Reduction Act would help create a
market for renewable and carbon-free technology that was so favorable
that big investments in fossil fuels simply would not make much economic
sense in the future.
“Politicians
aren’t going to turn that around, post this Inflation Reduction Act,
which is going to unleash an amazing amount of energy in this
transition,” he said.
Jeff Stein in Washington and Allyson Chiu in Pittsburgh contributed to this report.