[Salon] Brazil Riots: The Aftermath of Pro-Bolsonaro Protests



https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/brazil-protests-bolsonaro-congress?mod=djemalertNEWS

View highlights only
1 hour ago
An entrance to the Niemeyer-designed Alvorada presidential palace was damaged during the rioting in Brasília on Sunday.carl de souza/Agence France-Presse/Getty Images

The mob attacks on Brazil’s presidential palace, Supreme Court and Congress on Sunday weren't only an attack on President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s government, as his aides have described them.

They also damaged the modernist structures designed by architect Oscar Niemeyer that helped prompt UNESCO to designate Brasília as a World Heritage Site.

Videos posted on social media showed antigovernment protesters smashing windows, destroying furniture and setting fires in the buildings that Mr. Niemeyer designed in the 1950s and are known for their curves, swerves and spirals.

Built from scratch over a five-year period and inaugurated in 1960, Brasília was envisioned as a modern utopia with a radical urban plan that would be free of congestion and slums. In 2020, Architectural Digest wrote that Brasília’s “bold monumentality demonstrated how Brazil wanted to be perceived by the world: a progressive power.”

At the heart of Brasília, the country’s fourth-largest city with 2.5 million people, is the government sector, which is anchored by Mr. Niemeyer’s futuristic structures. The buildings have long been celebrated by architects around the world. In a 2000 interview, Mr. Niemeyer told the BBC: “I dedicated myself to finding a new solution, something that would attract attention.” Mr. Niemeyer, a member of the board that designed the United Nations, died in 2012, at age 104.

One of the buildings that makes up the National Congress, for example, suggests the space age with white, saucer-like structures on the roof. The Alvorada presidential palace combines marble columns, a glass facade and reflecting pools.

But not everyone liked the results. In 2017, Brazil’s then-president, Michel Temer, moved out of the presidential palace because of what he claimed were its bad vibes. He suggested that it might be haunted by ghosts.

Even before Sunday’s protests, the presidential palace was reportedly in a state of disrepair. Last week, the Brazilian TV channel GloboNews toured the building with first lady Rosângela da Silva. She complained of damaged carpets, torn sofas, broken windows and floorboards, and missing artwork.

1 hour ago
Brazilian Justice Minister Flávio Dino described the protests as 'terrorist attacks.'mauro pimentel/Agence France-Presse/Getty Images

Brazilian parties from both sides of the political divide signed a petition Monday to open a congressional inquiry into the attacks on government buildings by supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro and determine who, if anyone, may have financed the rioters.

Supporters of the army captain-turned-politician forced their way into the presidential palace, Congress and Supreme Court in the capital Sunday afternoon. Many of them called for a military intervention to oust President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, who took office Jan. 1.

Brazil’s new justice minister, Flávio Dino, said late Sunday that investigators had identified the individuals who paid for 40 buses to bring Mr. Bolsonaro's supporters to Brasília for the attacks. He said they were in the process of being arrested, without naming them.

Mr. Dino also opened a public hotline Monday for any information on the protests, which he described as “terrorist attacks.”

“Criminals will be treated as criminals,” he said. “They will not be allowed to destroy Brazilian democracy.”

Antônio Gontijo, a 66-year-old retired mechanic who attended the protests in Brasília, said businessmen in his town helped pay for him to travel from Minas Gerais state. “Our fight is for our family, for the future of our nation,” he said.

Politicians called for answers.

“We urgently need a congressional inquiry to see who is financing this and which authorities, at the federal and local level, are behind these acts and allowed them to occur,” said Juliano de Medeiros, head of the leftist PSOL party, in a televised interview. He also called for the Supreme Court’s help to jail those responsible, in comments later posted to Twitter.

In the lead-up to Brazil’s presidential election in October, which Mr. da Silva won with 51% of the vote, the Supreme Court had begun investigating a handful of wealthy businessmen and accused them of discussing a possible power grab in the event that Mr. Bolsonaro lost.

2 hours ago
President Biden was welcomed by Mexican President Andrés Manuel López Obrador on Sunday at an airport near Mexico City.Andrew Harnik/Associated Press

The leaders of the U.S., Mexico and Canada, who are meeting this week in Mexico City for a summit, condemned Sunday’s storming of the Brazilian Congress, Supreme Court and presidential palace by supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro.

“We stand with Brazil as it safeguards its democratic institutions. Our governments support the free will of the people of Brazil,” the three said in a joint statement released by the White House.

Many of the protesters called for military intervention to oust Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, who took office a week ago after winning the October election by a narrow margin.

“We look forward to working with President Lula on delivering for our countries, the Western Hemisphere, and beyond,” President Biden, Mexican President Andrés Manuel López Obrador and Canadian Primer Minister Justin Trudeau said.

Mr. López Obrador, who met Mr. Biden upon the U.S. president's arrival in Mexico City on Sunday, said it wasn’t necessary to discuss the events in Brazil since both governments had already made their positions known, as had Canada.

“We’re going to continue supporting President Lula, who was elected democratically,” he said at his morning press conference.

The three heads of state will meet Tuesday in the Mexican capital and also plan to hold separate bilateral meetings.

Updated 2 hours ago
Jair Bolsonaro criticized protesters who stormed government buildings.Bruna Prado/Associated Press

A few days before former President Jair Bolsonaro’s supporters stormed government buildings in Brasília, videos on social media showed the conservative ex-leader wandering around a shopping market in Orlando, Fla.

Mr. Bolsonaro had left Brazil for the Sunshine State after losing a bitter election to his leftist rival, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, following a campaign marred by violence that targeted politicians on the left and right.

He has criticized supporters who stormed the government buildings in the capital, saying, “Peaceful demonstrations, within the law, are part of democracy. However, vandalism and the invasion of public buildings like today’s acts, and like those practiced by the left in 2013 and 2017, are an exception," referring to previous waves of protests in the country.

In early November, Mr. Bolsonaro addressed the nation following his loss in the presidential election and agreed to a transition of power, but didn’t directly concede the election in his remarks.

Mr. Bolsonaro didn’t attend the inauguration of Mr. da Silva, and had condemned some violent demonstrations by his supporters, who had blocked highways and clashed with police as they tried to force their way into the Federal Police headquarters in Brasília in mid-December.

Mr. Bolsonaro, who has frequently expressed admiration for former President Donald Trump, was the nation’s first right-wing president since the end of military rule three decades ago. He adopted a similar style of politics to the American leader, often communicating via combative messages on Twitter.

In early 2019, Mr. Bolsonaro’s visited Washington, D.C., to meet with Mr. Trump less than three months after the former army captain took office. He broke with tradition as Brazilian presidents typically first tour South American countries.

2 hours ago
Supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro sat in front of police inside the official presidential workplace in the capital Brasília on Sunday.Eraldo Peres/Associated Press

The violent attacks in Brazil’s capital by supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro on Sunday showed that his electoral defeat didn’t spell the end of a far-right movement that remains well-funded and organized to act as a force for civil disruption, analysts say.

It is also a reminder of the governing challenges President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva faces, said Hasnain Malik, head of equity research at emerging-markets analysis firm Tellimer Research. A large section of Congress opposes Mr. da Silva, meaning legislative deal-making will be difficult, Mr. Malik said in a note to investors on Monday.

Still, the attacks didn’t alter the transition of power and the military coup craved by some far-right activists looks very unlikely, he said.

Hundreds of rioters have been arrested as federal security forces recovered control of government buildings.

On Sunday, Mr. da Silva accused Brasília’s military police of not acting to contain the protesters. “They did absolutely nothing,” Mr. da Silva said of the military police, which counts many supporters of Mr. Bolsonaro—a former army captain—among its ranks.

“If there is a faction in the military that supports a coup, then it is worth bearing in mind that any associated commercial interests unambiguously would be damaged by a coup, given the likelihood of capital flight [and] the U.S. sanctions that would ensure,” Mr. Malik said.

Latin America’s largest economy also ranks as the region’s top crude-oil producer at a time of increased geopolitical instability sparked by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

2 hours ago
Brazilian Army officers stood guard in front of a camp of supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro in Brasília on Monday.Andre Borges/Shutterstock

Brazil isn't the only Latin American country grappling with protests, as some countries face a gloomy economic outlook and grassroots movements seeking to upend the status quo.

“I don’t think this is going to be a quiet year on the streets of South America,” said Michael Shifter, a Latin America expert at the Inter-American Dialogue, a Washington, D.C., think tank. “It is going to be volatile.”

Economic growth in Latin America is expected to slow this year to 1.7% from about 3.5% last year, according to the International Monetary Fund. The IMF says the slowdown is due to tighter global financing conditions, weaker global growth and commodity prices and entrenched inflation.

William Jackson, an economist at Capital Economics, says the growing political instability in Latin America has its roots in “an extremely weak macroeconomic backdrop over the past decade as well as high levels of inequality.”

That has “created fertile ground for anti-incumbency votes, shifts to populism, and polarized and fragmented legislatures,” he said.

In Peru, unrest has emerged in several cities since Dec. 7. That is when President Pedro Castillo, a former rural schoolteacher with no governing experience, attempted to dissolve the Congress. He was swiftly removed from power, detained and replaced by his vice president, Dina Boluarte. She is struggling to consolidate control as she seeks to hold elections in 2024, two years ahead of schedule.

In Bolivia, demonstrations are rocking the prosperous eastern province of Santa Cruz after security forces locked up the conservative governor, Luis Fernando Camacho. He is an critic of leftist President Luis Arce and leader of 2019 protests that sparked the ouster of former President Evo Morales.

In Chile, another leftist president, former student activist Gabriel Boric, has seen his approval ratings plummet since he took office in March 2022. According to a poll by Cadem, 70% of Chileans disapprove of Mr. Boric’s handling of the government, up from 61% at the end of December before he issued controversial pardons for jailed protestors who participated in October 2019 demonstrations.

Colombian President Gustavo Petro, a fellow leftist who took office in August, is on a state visit to Chile today. Mr. Petro and Mr. Boric are expected to issue a joint declaration that is likely to highlight their support for Brazil’s new President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.

3 hours ago
Members of the military dismantle a tent at a camp made by supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro.AMANDA PEROBELLI/REUTERS

Brazil’s military began Monday to dismantle camps set up by supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro who ransacked government buildings on Sunday.

Brazil’s Supreme Court ordered the camps, which had been set up in Brasília since October’s election, be removed within 24 hours after Mr. Bolsonaro’s supporters stormed the presidential palace, Congress and Supreme Court on Sunday.

Local media showed Brazilian soldiers taking down blue and yellow tarps and removing sleeping mats. Protesters in the camps said they wanted the military to oust President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva after he defeated Mr. Bolsonaro in last year’s election. Mr. da Silva took office last week, while Mr. Bolsonaro left for Florida without attending the inauguration or conceding.

“The events will strengthen the resolve of the new government to put an end to anti-democratic camps and demonstrations that have persisted since the elections,” says Mario Marconini, a Brazil analyst at Teneo consultancy. “An unprecedented unity of the three branches of government is expected to emerge in defense of the rule of law and the preservation of democracy.”

On Monday, officials were taking stock of the damage from yesterday’s riots by a mob that smashed windows and ripped up furniture in the government buildings. Some 300 people were arrested yesterday, with tensions remaining high in Brasília early Monday.

Mr. da Silva is expected to hold an emergency council meeting on Monday and also meet with governors to beef up security.

4 hours ago
Government property in Brasília was damaged in protests.UESLEI MARCELINO/REUTERS

Brazil’s real currency opened weaker against the U.S. dollar on Monday, a day after violent protests by supporters of ex-president Jair Bolsonaro rocked the nation’s capital demanding newly-inaugurated President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva be ousted.

The real was down about 1% against the dollar in early trading, according to Tullett Prebon data, amid broader concerns about political upheaval in Latin America’s largest nation.

While the attack on government buildings, including the presidential palace, was mainly a political shock, it could have “long-lasting risk premium on the country’s financial assets,” says William Jackson, an economist at Capital Economics.

The economic implications of yesterday’s upheaval will depend in part on whether it is a one-off or recurring event, Mr. Jackson says. Previous protests by truck drivers, for example, resulted in a decline in industrial production and rise in inflation, Mr. Jackson notes.

“Yesterday’s events provide a timely reminder that discontent with the election and Lula’s presidency remains high in some quarters,” he says. “Were protests to become more frequent and/or spread to more critical sectors, the economic costs would become larger.”

Another risk to the economy could arise if Mr. da Silva, feeling his presidency is under assault, embraces the more left-wing parts of his agenda, including higher social welfare spending, a bigger role for the state in the economy and a reduced role for market forces.

“There are lots of ways that economic effects can materialize, including a lack of governability that prevents policymakers from tackling key economic challenges, and higher public spending and larger budget deficits to shore up support,” Mr. Jackson says. “But this would come at the cost of raising public debt risks.”

4 hours ago
An official stepped through debris at the Planalto Palace in Brasília on Monday.andre coelho/Shutterstock
5 hours ago

Brazil’s Supreme Court Orders Removal of Brasília Governor Ibaneis Rocha After Protests

UESLEI MARCELINO/REUTERS

BRASÍLIA – Brazil’s Supreme Court ordered Monday that the governor of the federal district of Brasília be removed from his post after thousands of protesters stormed the presidential palace here Sunday in what officials said was an attempt to overthrow the country’s newly-elected leftist president.

Protesters supporting Brazil’s former President Jair Bolsonaro forced their way into the presidential palace, Congress and the Supreme Court in the capital Sunday afternoon, many calling for military intervention to oust Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, who took office a week ago.

Riot police had forced protesters back out into the streets by nightfall Sunday and some 300 people had been arrested. Tensions remained high in Brasília early Monday, with some supporters of the president saying they expected more protesters to arrive in the capital from other parts of the country.

In an order issued in the early hours of Monday, Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes told police to clear the camps and demanded that Ibaneis Rocha, Brasília’s governor and an ally of Mr. Bolsonaro, be removed from his post for the next three months. Mr. Moraes said that the attacks “could only have occurred with the consent, and even active participation, of the competent authorities for public security and intelligence.”

Before the court order, Mr. Rocha said on Twitter he had done everything possible to contain the attacks.

Read the full article

6 hours ago
Pope Francis added a last-minute reference to Brazil into his speech.Andrew Medichini/Associated Press

Pope Francis said Sunday's attack on government institutions in Brazil was part of a broader trend of weakening democracy, especially in the Americas.

The pope added a reference to Brazil at the last minute to the prepared text of his annual speech to ambassadors accredited to the Holy See, whom he addressed on Monday morning at the Vatican.

"In many areas, a sign of the weakening of democracy is heightened political and social polarization, which does not help to resolve the urgent problems of citizens," the pope said.

"I think of the various countries of the Americas where political crises are laden with tensions and forms of violence that exacerbate social conflicts. I think in particular of recent events in Peru and, in these last few hours, in Brazil, and the worrying situation in Haiti, where steps are finally being taken to address the political crisis that has been underway for some time."

Thousands of protestors stormed the presidential palace, Congress and the Supreme Court in Brazil's capital city of Brasília on Sunday.

In Peru last month, supporters of former President Pedro Castillo carried out deadly protests after he was ousted by lawmakers following his attempt to dissolve Congress. Haiti has experienced a spiraling economic and security crisis since the still-unsolved 2021 assassination of President Jovenel Moïse.

8 hours ago
Sunday’s riots come after one of the most polarized election campaigns in Brazil’s recent democratic period.Ton Molina/Zuma Press

President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva is just over a week into his term, but political analysts say that Sunday’s riots underscore the risks that his presidency, and Brazilian democracy, will face from far-right opponents in Latin America’s largest nation.

“It’s a very powerful signal that this is going to be a very contentious, confrontational presidency and he’s going to have a very hard time,” said Michael Shifter, a Latin America expert at the Inter-American Dialogue, a Washington, D.C., think tank.

Mr. Shifter expects that Mr. da Silva will get a short-term political boost after a mob of supporters of his conservative predecessor, ex-president Jair Bolsonaro, stormed government buildings in the Brazilian capital.

But that will likely be temporary, he said. Mr. Shifter said the attacks on Sunday “makes it clear that this kind of polarization and bitterness and hatred” in Brazilian politics is here to stay after last year’s presidential election campaign was marred by violence.

“It underscores the serious difficulties [Lula’s] going to have in governing. It is a very clear sign that this is going to be very complicated,” said Mr. Shifter.

Political upheaval that risks undermining Brazil’s democracy could also batter the nation’s economy, analysts say. Brazil is Latin America’s top oil producer, and has taken on a growing role in the international oil market at a time of high energy costs.



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.