[Salon] Not the time for a ceasefire in Gaza, says US, with Hamas still holding hostages



https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/oct/24/us-no-gaza-ceasefire-hamas-hostages?CMP=share_btn_link

Not the time for a ceasefire in Gaza, says US, with Hamas still holding hostages

Some Palestinians returning to north of Gaza owing to lack of food; Emmanuel Macron visits Israel

Rory Carroll in Jerusalem
Tue 24 Oct 2023
First published on Mon 23 Oct 2023

The US has said now is not the time for a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas, as the UN reports that some Palestinians who fled their homes in the north of Gaza have returned due to a lack of food and shelter in the south.

The White House national security spokesperson John Kirby told CNN on Monday that Israel still had “work to do to go after Hamas leadership”, echoing comments from the US president, Joe Biden, that any discussions of a ceasefire could only take place if Hamas freed all its hostages in Gaza.

The statement from the White House was at odds with comments from UN and EU officials who on Monday called for a humanitarian pause in fighting so that aid could be delivered into Gaza.

France’s president, Emmanuel Macron, was expected to express solidarity with Israel and call for the “preservation” of Gaza’s civilian population during a visit to Israel on Tuesday. After meeting relatives of French-Israeli citizens killed in Hamas’s attack on 7 October, he was to hold talks with Israeli leaders and Palestinian officials in the West Bank.

The families of two Israeli hostages released by Hamas on Monday night celebrated their return. Yokheved Lifshitz, 85, and Nurit Yitzhak, 79, were reunited with their families at a Tel Aviv hospital, where medical staff said both women appeared in good health.

Lifshitz told the Ynet news site that Hamas had “schooled” Israel in its murderous assault. She said she did not know where she had been held in Gaza. “They loaded me on to a motorcycle … with one terrorist holding me from the front and the other from behind so that I wouldn’t fall. We crossed the border fence into the strip, and at first they held me in the town of Abasan al-Kabir. After that, I don’t know where I was taken.”

Freed Israeli hostage filmed extending hand to Hamas militant in video released by group – video

Qatar and Egypt helped to broker the release of the two women. Israeli media reported that the US and Qatar were trying to broker a deal in which 50 dual nationals held by Hamas would be released.

Meanwhile, Israeli police reportedly detained a prominent Arab Israeli actor, Maisa Abd Elhadi, for allegedly posting images in support of Hamas. Israeli media said Abd Elhadi, who appeared in the TV show Baghdad Central and the film World War Z, was arrested on suspicion of incitement and support for terrorism.

Concern about the plight of people in Gaza intensified. The director of the UN agency for Palestinian refugees (UNRWA) in Gaza, Thomas White, said shortages of shelter, food and drinking water in the south had forced some residents to return to their homes in the north.

Israel delivered sweeping evacuation orders for almost half of Gaza’s 2.3 million people on 13 October. The UN estimates that almost two-thirds of Gaza’s population have been displaced over the last two weeks.

“People have left everything in the north … they have come to the south where they are struggling to find shelter, food is scarce, many people are having to drink unpotable water, so the situation in the south is dire,” White told the BBC.

Red Crescent workers sort aid newly arrived in Gaza.
Red Crescent workers sort aid newly arrived in Gaza. Photograph: Majdi Fathi/NurPhoto/Shutterstock

The Israeli military bombed a refugee camp in Gaza’s north late on Monday, reports said. The IDF said the strike targeted a staging ground for Hamas. Palestinian media reported that five people were killed.

Gaza’s health authority, which is run by Hamas, has said at least 5,087 people have been killed in Israel’s two-week bombardment, many of them children.

The conflict broke out after the Palestinian militants attacked southern Israeli communities on 7 October, killing 1,400 people and taking 222 hostages into the strip.

On Sunday it emerged that the US had pressed Israel to delay its expected ground assault on Gaza to allow time for the release of more hostages and the delivery of more aid.


The Maariv newspaper said the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, and his generals were at odds over when to launch a ground invasion. Quoting unnamed senior Israeli officials, the daily said the Israeli leader was delaying it while there was still a possibility of returning the captives, and that the “initial phrase” of the Israeli offensive – airstrikes – was “not yet exhausted”.

Netanyahu’s office put out a statement on Monday night denying the reports of friction, saying: “The prime minister, the defence minister and the IDF chief of staff are working in close and full cooperation … there is total and mutual trust.”

Israel pounded hundreds of targets in Gaza from the air on Monday, with a military spokesperson suggesting there was no intention of curbing its strikes on the densely populated area.

“The path is a path of unrelenting attacks, damaging Hamas everywhere and in every way, said the Israeli chief of staff, Lt Gen Herzi Halevi, adding: “We are well prepared for the ground operations.”

US officials speaking to the New York Times said the Biden administration was concerned that Israeli forces did not have a clear military plan of action to achieve their goal of eradicating Hamas.

The Pentagon has sent military advisers, including a marine corps general versed in urban warfare, to Israel to aid in its war planning and has sent air defence systems to the Middle East ahead of the anticipated ground assault into Gaza.



  • This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.