[There is absolutely no reason to believe the IDF spokesman's evidence-free 'preliminary assessment' that the hostages, who had survived nearly 11 months in the custody of Hamas, were killed by Hamas rather than by IDF bombs or gunfire. The IDF has a well-established reputation for deceit. It initially claimed that the Israelis killed at "the Rave" just outside Gaza on October 7 were murdered by Hamas or other Palestinians when, in fact, at least half of those who perished on that day were killed under the Hannibal Directive by Hellfire missiles from Israeli helicopters, tank fire, or indiscriminate fire from IDF troops. Skepticism is in order about IDF's self-serving claims in the absence of evidence.]Protests escalate in Israel after 6 hostages’ bodies are recovered in Gaza
Hersh Goldberg-Polin, an Israeli American, and five others Hamas took hostage on Oct. 7 were killed “shortly before” being found, the Israel Defense Forces said.
Undated portraits provided Sunday by the Hostages Families Forum Headquarters show (clockwise from top left) Almog Sarusi, Alexander Lobanov, Carmel Gat, Ori Danino, Eden Yerushalmi and Hersh Goldberg-Polin. The Israeli military said it found their bodies in a tunnel in southern Gaza. (Hostages Families Forum Headquarters/AFP/Getty Images)Updated September 1, 2024 at 12:31 p.m. EDT|Published September 1, 2024 at 12:15 a.m. EDTTEL AVIV — Israelis reacted with shock and fury Sunday after the bodies of six more hostages were recovered by the military from Gaza, with Israeli authorities saying they were killed in recent days by their captors.
Tens of thousands of protesters were expected to take part in nationwide protests Sunday night, and Israel’s largest labor union called for a general strike Monday — threatening to shut down the country until Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu agreed to a deal with Hamas to return the remaining captives.
The parents of Hersh Goldberg-Polin, an American being held hostage in Gaza, spoke about their anguish over their missing son at the DNC on Aug. 21. (Video: The Washington Post, Photo: Ricky Carioti/The Washington Post)Among those recovered Saturday from Gaza by the Israeli military was Israeli-American Hersh Goldberg-Polin, 23, whose parents have become globally known ambassadors for the hostage family movement and who spoke last month at the Democratic National Convention.
“Needing our only son — and all of the cherished hostages — home is not a political issue. It is a humanitarian issue,” Jon Polin, Hersh’s father, said at the time.
Their son’s remains were found alongside the bodies of Carmel Gat, 40; Eden Yerushalmi, 24; Alexander Lobanov, 32; Almog Sarusi, 27; and Ori Danino, 25.
The IDF said they were killed by Hamas “shortly before” being retrieved from a tunnel, several dozen feet deep, in the southern Gazan city of Rafah. It was roughly half a mile from the tunnel where the IDF rescued a living hostage, Bedouin Israeli Farhan al-Qadi, last week.
The bodies were taken to the National Center of Forensic Medicine, where an examination determined the six had been killed by “multiple close-range gunshots” within the last 48 to 72 hours, according to Shira Solomon, a spokesperson for Israel’s Ministry of Health.
Hamas, in a statement, blamed Israeli bombings for the deaths, adding that “if President [Joe] Biden is concerned about their lives, he must stop supporting this enemy with money and weapons and pressure the occupation to end its aggression immediately.”
Hamas is still holding 97 hostages, including two children under the age of 5. Of those, 33 have already been declared dead by Israeli authorities. Over nearly 11 months of agonizing uncertainty, hostage families have accused Netanyahu of prioritizing his political survival over a deal that would bring their loved ones home, and on Sunday they demanded he address the nation.
What they got instead was a recorded statement from his office: “The fact that Hamas continues to commit atrocities like the ones it committed on the 7th of October obliges us to do everything so that it cannot commit these atrocities again,” Netanyahu said.
“Whoever murders hostages does not want a deal,” he said, saying Hamas has refused “to conduct real negotiations.”
Yet it is Netanyahu, negotiators say, who has been one of the main barriers to a deal. He has insisted on maintaining an Israeli presence along the Philadelphi Corridor, a strategic buffer zone between Gaza and Egypt that Israel says is used by Hamas to smuggle weapons, a claim denied by Cairo. On Thursday, the Israeli cabinet voted to remain in the corridor, despite warnings from high-ranking members of the security establishment that the move could torpedo a deal.
Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, who has emerged as one of the most vociferous critics of Netanyahu’s war strategy, demanded Sunday that the “cabinet must gather immediately and reverse the decision.” Protesters knelt in the streets and held up pictures of the hostages as Netanyahu and his ministers met in Jerusalem on Sunday night.
The six captives recovered Saturday, violently abducted from a music festival and a nearby kibbutz in southern Israel on Oct. 7, had been classified as alive by the IDF, which had a general assessment of their location. At least four of them — including Goldberg-Polin — were presumed to be on the list of hostages who would be released in the event of U.S.-brokered cease-fire.
In a statement, Biden said that after months of working alongside Goldberg-Polin’s parents and the families of other Israeli American hostages, he was “devastated and outraged” by the news of his death.
“Make no mistake, Hamas leaders will pay for these crimes,” he said. “And we will keep working around the clock for a deal to secure the release of the remaining hostages.”
Vice President Kamala Harris condemned Hamas’s brutality in a statement, calling Goldberg-Polin’s death a “terrible loss.”
Nearly 1,200 people were killed and more than 250 hostages dragged back to Gaza by Hamas militants on Oct. 7. During a one-week pause in fighting in late November, 105 hostages were released. Only eight hostages have been rescued by the IDF alive. Their fate has captivated Israel, with each sign of life a source of fleeting hope, and each recovered body and death notice a new trauma.
Families of hostages have flooded the streets of Tel Aviv again and again demanding that Netanyahu agree to a cease-fire that would secure the release of the hostages, even if it meant compromising on his promise of “total victory” over Hamas. Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, an Israeli military spokesman, has repeatedly said that only a negotiated deal would bring back most of them; Gallant has said the IDF is prepared to pay whatever operation price is required for their freedom.
On Sunday, dozens of restaurants, theaters, businesses and municipalities announced that they were shutting their doors in solidarity with the protests, and the national workers union announced an open-ended general strike starting Monday.
“We can no longer stand by while our children are suffering and being murdered in the tunnels of Gaza,” Arnon Bar-David, the head of the Histadrut labor union, said in a statement Sunday after meeting with hostage families. “This is unacceptable, and it must stop.”
Aviva Siegel, a former Israeli hostage whose husband Keith, a dual American-Israeli citizen, is still being held in Gaza, said that although she has lost faith in the Israeli government, she hopes Sunday’s grim news will finally force a deal into existence.
“I remember being there and feeling death above my head all the time,” said Siegel, who plans to participate in the demonstrations. “We need to scream aloud for them to be brought home. I’m not going to lose my hope. That would break me into pieces.”
Hostages' relatives and supporters protest in Tel Aviv last month to demand a cease-fire and the release of those held in Gaza. (Heidi Levine/FTWP)The Hostage Families Forum, an umbrella organization representing most of the hostages’ families, said in a statement that the six “were taken alive, endured the horrors of captivity, and were then coldly murdered.” It added that a deal for their return had been “on the table” for two months. It blamed their deaths on “delays, sabotage and excuses.”
Israeli President Isaac Herzog said the “heart of an entire nation is shattered to pieces” and apologized to the families for failing to bring them back safely.
Opposition leader Yair Lapid took aim at Netanyahu’s government, saying the deaths could have been prevented through an agreement. “Instead of saving lives, hostages are being buried. Instead of doing everything to bring them home, Netanyahu is doing all he can to stay in power,” he said.
Four of the recovered hostages — Yerushalmi, Lobanov, Sarusi and Danino — were laid to rest on Sunday. Goldberg-Polin will be buried in a ceremony in Jerusalem on Monday.
Goldberg-Polin was celebrating his 23rd birthday at the Nova music festival when it was overrun by gunmen.
“With broken hearts, the Goldberg-Polin family is devastated to announce the death of their beloved son and brother, Hersh,” the family said in a statement Sunday, thanking their supporters and appealing for privacy.
At the Democratic National Convention in August, Rachel Goldberg-Polin said her son’s “left forearm, his dominant arm, was blown off before he was loaded onto a pickup truck and stolen from his life — and me and Jon — into Gaza.”
“That was 320 days ago,” she said. “Since then, we live on another planet.”
In April, Hersh Goldberg-Polin appeared in a propaganda video released by Hamas, reading from an apparently scripted statement condemning Netanyahu.
The Hostage Families Forum paid tribute Sunday to all the deceased captives. Lobanov was a father of two, including a baby born while he was in captivity who is now 2 months old. Gat was an occupational therapist who loved solo travel. Danino was planning to start his studies to become an engineer.
The forum described Yerushalmi as a devoted sister who spoke to her family for hours as she tried to escape the Hamas attack. Sarusi, it said, was at the Nova festival with his girlfriend, who was murdered.
Masih reported from Seoul, Slater from Williamstown, Mass and Soroka from Tel Aviv. Alon Rom in Tel Aviv and Steve Hendrix in Jerusalem contributed to this report.
