[Salon] A tale of two Maghreb economies



A tale of two Maghreb economies

Summary: under King Mohammed VI Morocco continues to build on its economy with a strategy that is open to the world while Tunisia’s President Kais Saied has decided to look inward alienating foreign investment and crippling the private sector.

We thank our regular contributor Francis Ghilès for today’s newsletter. Francis is Visiting Fellow King’s College London and Associate Research Fellow CIDOB, Barcelona. You will find his most recent AD podcast Macron in Morocco here.

The latest IMF report on Morocco suggests that the kingdom’s GDP per capita will overtake that of Tunisia next year, reaching US$4471 as against US$4396 for North Africa’s smallest nation. This difference in favour of Morocco will, all other things being equal accelerate in the years ahead to reach 22% by the end of the decade in 2029. Economic growth in the kingdom is running at twice the equivalent of Tunisia and will accelerate to threefold over the four years to come.

By regional standards, this is a sharp reversal of roles which can be explained by Morocco’s embrace of a growing internationalisation of its economy and increased role of private investment, be it domestic or foreign. It has also managed its public finances and contained inflation better than Tunisia and avoided its foreign debt lurching out of control.

For several decades capital investment as a percentage of GDP was running at an annual average of 25.9% in both countries. Since 2015 that started to diverge. By 2020, investment as a percentage of GDP in Morocco had accelerated to 33.4% in contrast to Tunisia where it had declined to 21.5%, a figure which has dropped since and is expected to reach a historic low of 11.2%. Morocco’s figure for 2024 is expected to be 27.8%.

Since the turn of the century, Moroccan governments, whatever their political colour have promoted reforms aimed at integrating the country into the world economy, signing many free trade agreements and promoting private investment. The founding and continued expansion of the Tangier Med port and the growing footprint internationally of the kingdom’s important phosphate and fertiliser sector has been remarkable. The Open Skies policy has hugely boosted the number of airlines flying to Morocco and with it the tourists they bring. The growing public/private sector cooperation has freed government funds for other key sectors. The driving force behind these changes has been the monarchy which carries more weight than governments. King Hassan II until 1999 and Mohamed VI since have stuck to what is turning out to be a winning strategy.


Moroccan car manufacturer Somaca’s Casablanca plant is expected to set a new production record this year of over 100,000 vehicles [photo credit: Moroccan Trade Ministry]

Tunisia’s leaders have adopted a different strategy. For the eight years after the fall of Ben Ali in 2011 they pretended to reform the country’s very corporatist economy, to please the IMF and the World Bank but never did enact any reforms. The strategic phosphate and fertiliser sector was prone to endless strikes and mismanagement, the Open Skies policy was refused to the detriment of the important tourist sector and banks continued to ignore the very active SME sector.

Since coming to power in 2019, President Kais Saied has made fighting corruption and maintaining the standard of living of the poorest his mantras. A few businessmen may be in prison but the private sector on the whole is missing in action. Private foreign investors have deserted the country or closed factories and moved abroad. Relations with the IMF are effectively frozen. This policy of turning in on itself has killed one of the key factors in any policy of economic growth, investment, which has fallen to historic lows.

Some key economic indicators illustrate the growing divergence between the two nations. Morocco had an average inflation rate of 2.2% between 2015 and 2024, Tunisia of 6.3%. Inflation in Morocco in 2024 is 1.7% but 7.1% in its near neighbour. The kingdom’s foreign indebtedness stands at 69.1% of GDP in 2024, Tunisia at 83.7%. Tunisia has difficulty raising international loans because of its standoff with the IMF which carries two consequences: foreign loans are more expensive and the state’s recourse to local bank loans crowds out the private sector, especially the SMEs.

In other words, Morocco continues to industrialise while Tunisia is de-industrialising. Industry accounts on average for 25.8% of GDP since 2020 in the kingdom. The figure is 23.3% in Tunisia. According to the IMF these figures will continue to diverge. A generation ago, Tunisia was often quoted as a model of economic development in Africa and the Middle East by the World Bank, an exaggeration as later events were to prove. A number of observers in the West were not prepared to bet the Moroccan monarchy would last until the next generation. Events have proven them wrong. Both countries are run by autocratic regimes but Morocco’s is far more enlightened, economically at least, than its neighbour to the east.

Members can leave comments about this newsletter on the Arab Digest website


follow us on TwitterLinkedIn and Facebook

Copyright © 2024 Arab Digest, All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email as you are subscribed to the Arab Digest.
Our mailing address is:
Arab Digest
3rd Floor
207 Regent Street
London, W1B 3HH
United Kingdom



 To unsubscribe from this list email editor@arabdigest.org


This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.