Re: [Salon] Open letter to Dr. Riyad Mansour, representative of the State of Palestine to the United Nations



This is clearly v. well-meaning & heartfelt appeal. However, in the late-June Zoom meeting in which Mr. Rubin proposed & explained his planned appeal, his main guest in that Zoom, the former UN HRC official Craig Mokhiber made an excellent contribution, that included these points:

 If the State of Palestine requests the Resolution, troops can legally enter Gaza and the rest of Palestine as well, as the ICJ has found that Israel has no sovereignty or authority in Gaza, the West Bank, or East Jerusalem, and their presence there is entirely unlawful. Thus, the only required consent is the State of Palestine, (although the resolution should also call for full cooperation from Egypt and Jordan to facilitate the staging and entry of the UN force). 

·         The State of Palestine would be the best, quickest, and most favorable UN member to approve the resolution and submit it to the UN General Assembly, but any country can call for an ESS of the GA to begin the same process. Co-sponsors from a small group of core countries from each region of the world should be sought and lobbied, such as South Africa, Namibia, Spain, Ireland, and Norway. The State of Palestine and the General Assembly would then decide which countries would send troops and armaments into Gaza, and potentially the West Bank and East Jerusalem.

·         The entire State of Palestine is also under occupation and faces difficulties; acknowledging this and understanding the political dynamics and contradictions there can help us understand how to best approach and work with them...


Craig's last point there is crucial! The "State of Palestine"/ Palestinian Authority is a strange entity that is thus far effectively controlled by the PLO's Oslo Accords partners, namely the USA and Israel. Hence, while we see Riyad Mansour sometimes representing Palestinian interests with somewhat good effect at the UN in NYC, at the same time, back home in Ramallah the armed forces of the body that he represents, the PA/PLO, are working very actively with the Israeli occupation forces to crush all resistance to the occupation...

Hence, rather than focusing one's advocacy efforts on the PLO/Palestine mission to the UN, I judge it far better to focus them on supporting the work of intergovernmental bodies like the Hague Group. Though the Hague Group has not yet called for a UfP resolution in re Gaza, it has formulated some good interim actions that its members are committed to take, to dent Israel's war effort-- and it now lists 30 actual, voting states members of the UN in its coalition. From the states of West Asia only Iraq, Libya, Oman, and Türkiye are parties to the HG's commitment statement. (The others are: Bolivia, Colombia, Cuba, Indonesia, Malaysia, Namibia, Nicaragua, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, and South Africa. Not all the members of the HG signed the statement.)

Another point that needs to be remembered by all parties interested in exploring/using the "Uniting for Peace" procedure as a way to over-ride US veto power in the UNSC in re Gaza is that when UfP was used to greatest effect, back in late 1956, as a way to over-ride the UK and French vetoes at the UNSC in re the Tripartite Aggression they had launched, jointly with Israel, against Egypt, the main reason that UfP move worked was because US Pres. Dwight Eisenhower had not only initiated/supported it but he'd also communicated clearly to PM Eden and the French that he was quite prepared to use US economic power to sink the £ sterling and French franc, if need be.

I fear that we face a problem in that regard today. Unless and until the states of the Global Majority are prepared to act together to challenge the US government on the economic/financial playing field, just about all the words issuing from UNHQ in NYC will be hot air...
----------
Helena Cobban
She/her/they | Honoring the lives & legacies of the Piscataways in whose lands I live
More about me in my Linktree



On Thu, Aug 14, 2025 at 1:35 PM Chas Freeman via Salon <salon@listserve.com> wrote:
Dear Comrades,
Yesterday on my trip to NYC, one goal was to hand out the letter (see attachment) that I sent to Dr Monsour regarding his call for, “dispatch of an international protection force to the OPT (Occupied Palestinian Territories) and acceleration of unfettered humanitarian assistance by the UN and international organizations” to as many of the folks working in the Palestinian Mission as possible. The first person that the letter was handed to was no other than Dr. Monsour himself. I mentioned I had sent it to him on behalf of millions of people who support his call, but “we both know it has to come from you calling an ESS of the General Assembly calling for a Uniting for Peace Resolution”.  He didn’t comment, but he took the flyer and was reading it as he drove off.
The ask from you is this! he saw one old guy handing him a flyer, for all he knows I just came out of my basement and with delusional fantasies and am asking for this to happen.  What he needs to know NOW is that there are people all over the globe who unite with this letter, and are part of a movement calling for  his immediate action to implement what is in the letter.
He has the letter now. Let’s show him  just how widespread this feeling is!   You are all smart, and a form letter never gets as much attention as a personal one, so I am asking you to email Dr. Monsour NOW,  saying or paraphrasing “I am glad you personally were given our letter in front of the Palestinian Mission yesterday and just want you to know, that that letter  comes from me as well.   Put your name and country on it.  It should not be long, and does not have to list any atrocities or further reasons why he must do it. BUT IT MUST be written to him  as a friend and supporter of his Call, NOT as an antagonistic letter, no matter how much you want to include those feelings.  Unite with HIS call to action sent to the Security Council, but state that you recognize that the only path forward is for him to call an Emergency meeting of the General Assembly to call for a uniting for peace resolution with the inclusion of all which was in the letter he received yesterday.
If he receives a few thousand letters from around the globe, that may be the initial eye opener for him that people know the letter  to the SS is useless, but we are holding his words dear, and expecting him to act on those words in a way that he is capable of making it happen. 
8/14/25
Eric Rubin
Here is the letter I handed him:
Response to Dr. Riyad Mansour Permanent Observer Mission of the State of Palestine to United Nations Ref. SGC. 154/25 dated 25 July 2025.
Thank you for your bold and decisive document Permanent Observer Mission of the State of Palestine to the United Nations Ref. SGC. 154/25 dated 25 July 2025. In your position as the official voice of the State of Palestine your words are listened to and respected, and the world unites with your powerful statement and call for immediate and decisive action. “It is time to protect Palestinian civilians, including children, and to preserve their right to life, by the dispatch of an international protection force to the OPT (Occupied Palestinian Territories) and acceleration of unfettered humanitarian assistance by the UN and international organizations.”
However, we are not clear on why you have addressed this letter to H.E. Asim Iftikhar Ahmad, The President of the Security Council of the United Nations, with the following closing statement, "I should be grateful if you would arrange to have the present letter circulated to the Security Council members for their valuable consideration and distributed as an official document of the Security Council,”  when there is a way to circumvent the pitfalls of the Security Council and have the General Assembly move immediately to fulfil your request?
Instead, we urge you to call for something that can work and that can NOT be overridden by a Security Council veto,  and which has been used by other member states of the UN, to achieve their goals: Resolution 377 (V) Uniting For Peace, adopted on 3 November 1950, designed to empower the General Assembly to act when the Security Council is paralyzed by lack of unanimity among permanent members.
As we are sure you are aware of, any country can call for an ESS, but since Palestine is the State facing the genocide, if you as the official representative of the State of Palestine call for it, the mechanisms are obligated to immediately address your call, as the request will be from the State/Country under attack. In light of this, we respectfully request that you immediately call for an Emergency Special Session (ESS) of the General Assembly under the Uniting for Peace Resolution, with a draft text that includes the following measures:
I. Authorizing a UN-Mandated Multinational Armed Protective Force to Gaza
The force shall be armed for self-defense and equipped with advanced monitoring technologies.
·       Its mandate will include:
o   Safeguarding Palestinian civilians from further violence and displacement
o   Supporting the UN’s unrestricted entry and distribution of humanitarian aid, including efforts from civil society to break the siege by sea under the Global Sumud Flotilla Coalition
o   Preserving and securing evidence of potential war crimes and human rights violations
o   Facilitating the recovery and reconstruction of Gaza’s civilian infrastructure
II. Calls on All Member States to:
o   Mandate an immediate, lasting ceasefire, require Israel to withdraw all armed forces from Gaza, and halt all attacks by air, land, and sea
o   Impose a comprehensive arms embargo on Israel
o   Cease all trade, investment, economic, diplomatic, and cultural relations with the Israeli government
o   Strip Israel of its United Nations credentials
o   Reaffirm the right of the Palestinian people to use all necessary means to resist colonial domination and foreign occupation, including through armed struggle in accordance with international law
As you so clearly state “We appeal to all States to seize the occasion to implement their words and commitments with real, collective action to fulfill their legal, political, humanitarian and moral obligations to stop the genocide in Gaza and to finally end Israel’s illegal occupation of Palestine.
We urge you to act without delay to call for the ESS of the General Assembly on 29th July, 2025. With your call for the ESS for the implementation of the Uniting for Peace Resolution the concrete process enshrined in the United Nations would begin, not only to call on all General Assembly members to vote on this resolution, but also it begins the process of all member countries to assess what capabilities they can offer for the deployment of a UN mandated multinational armed protective force into Gaza immediately.
We will match your actions with global noise and support from the streets. Do the right thing and the world will support your call and stand with you.
Respectfully submitted,
Eric Rubin spokesperson for www.peopleagainstgenocideeverywhere.org  and our affiliated global partners
 
 

--
Salon mailing list
Salon@listserve.com
https://mlm2.listserve.net/mailman/listinfo/salon


This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.