Re: [Salon] Palestinians Are the Key to Saving Zionism (10/29/26)



Hmmm. She makes an interesting argument. My reactions were, in this order:
  1. Why would any Palestinian want to "save" Zionism?
  2. Indeed, would any real Zionist want to have their beloved colonial project "saved" by the Indigenes? and
  3. It seems much more likely that, rather than exploring a coalition with an Arab party or parties, the leaders of the two big Zionist fronts are prioritizing efforts to try to split off members of the opposing Zionist bloc and form a majority that way. Surely that should at least be mentioned?
----------
Helena Cobban
She/her/they | Honoring the lives & legacies of the Piscataways in whose lands I live
More about me in my Linktree



On Thu, Oct 29, 2026 at 8:52 AM Chas Freeman via Salon <salon@listserve.com> wrote:

Palestinians Are the Key to Saving Zionism 

Joint List party activists celebrate after the release of exit polls in Nazareth, northern Israel, on Tuesday.
Joint List party activists celebrate after the release of exit polls in Nazareth, northern Israel, on Tuesday. Credit: Daniel Rolider

The election results presented the "bloc of change" with a truth it refuses to acknowledge.

Mansour Abbas's willingness to push aside the national demands of Palestinian politics in favor of civic pragmatism, even by inviting a Jewish politician popular among Arabs to his slate, did not yield the desired number of Knesset seats. On both the right and left, the reserved attempts to legitimize Abbas were accompanied by the audacity to dictate the political boundaries for the Palestinian community: budgets and crime reduction – yes; national demands, a commitment to Palestinians beyond the separation barrier, opposition to the occupation, ethnic cleansing and genocide – no.

But the Palestinian community in Israel brushed it off, did not yield to Jewish directives and instead threw most of its support behind the Joint List. A party whose representatives were denounced by the right, center and parts of the Zionist left as nationalists, extremists and even terror supporters. "Israeli Arabs" cast a super-Palestinian ballot.

Moreover, even the reserved legitimacy that Abbas received was not enough to let him join a government coalition in the eyes of Gadi Eisenkot, Naftali Bennett and Avigdor Lieberman. A non-racist "bloc of change" would have jumped at the opportunity to replace Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu after the election. But even the desire to end Netanyahu's rule cannot match the fear of being labeled an "Arab-lover," or God forbid, treating them as political partners at this historic moment. Racism toward Arabs is proving to be a more dependable issue than opposition to Netanyahu.

The Palestinian public made a calculated, smart and historic political move in the election. The high voter turnout and the Joint List's new strength highlighted a simple issue to the Jewish community: There can be no government shake-up in the State of Israel without the Palestinians. The Palestinian public has become a factor that can determine the future of governance – all without relinquishing its national identity, its commitment to its own people or its political stances.

Now the "bloc of change" – which repeatedly discovers, but fails to grasp, that coalition arithmetic is not subject to its racism – will have to decide what it does with this historic opportunity. It can continue to court the Arab vote through inauthentic Arab representatives, while simultaneously shying away from the elected representatives of the Palestinian public. And above all, it can continue hoping that the Arab vote will not be necessary entirely – a full 20 percent of the population, unwanted by the coalition or opposition.

But this time this contradiction is not just morally shameful and stupid; it also has a political price in the form of Netanyahu's continued rule.

The State of Israel can be likened to a body with an immune system that identifies one of its vital organs as a threat and attacks, without realizing that it is damaging and destroying itself.

This is the same attitude toward Arab political power in the State of Israel. The 19 MKs from the Arab parties – if that is their final number – are an inseparable part of the political body that the State of Israel insists on fighting.

We are living through days of historical irony. Zionism, which in the name of self-defense seeks to push Palestinian nationalism beyond the bounds of legitimate politics, now faces the possibility that it specifically needs the Palestinians living in the State of Israel to save itself from self-destruction.

--
Salon mailing list
Salon@listserve.com
https://mlm2.listserve.net/mailman/listinfo/salon


This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.