[Salon] Fwd: Haaretz: "Israel's Opposition Won the Numbers to Defeat Netanyahu. It May Defeat Itself Instead." (10/29/26)



https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/elections/2026-10-29/ty-article/.premium/israels-opposition-won-the-numbers-to-defeat-netanyahu-it-may-defeat-itself/000001a1-875c-dabc-afb5-ffdeb1f90000https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/elections/2026-10-29/ty-article/.premium/israels-opposition-won-the-numbers-to-defeat-netanyahu-it-may-defeat-itself/000001a1-875c-dabc-afb5-ffdeb1f90000

10/29/26

Israel's Opposition Won the Numbers to Defeat Netanyahu. It May Defeat Itself Instead

Netanyahu's dominance opened the door to historic Arab-Jewish cooperation. But by capitulating to his anti-Arab rhetoric, Israel's opposition may squander it. Now it must choose which campaign promise to break: exclude Arab parties or oust Netanyahu

Yashar leader Gadi Eisenkot celebrates in Tel Aviv, Wednesday. Snatching defeat from the jaws of victory?
Yashar leader Gadi Eisenkot celebrates in Tel Aviv, Wednesday. Snatching defeat from the jaws of victory? Credit: Shir Torem / Reuters

The leaders of the anti-Netanyahu opposition set themselves the goal in this election of forming a non-Netanyahu-led government that did not depend on the support of the Arab-led parties or of the ultra-Orthodox parties. They insisted that this was their objective, and that they believed they could achieve it, even as no poll suggested such a scenario was possible.

As of this writing, the results have, in fact, confirmed what the polls had long shown. While there were surprises on Tuesday – the historic performance of the Arab-led parties, with an estimated 19 seats, and Likud's consolidation of right-wing support at the expense of its allies – the fundamental political dynamics have not changed in more than half a decade.

Joint List leader Yousef Jabareen and party members celebrate the exit polls in Nazareth on Tuesday. Despite the Arab parties' record gains, the opposition refuses to recognize that it can no longer form a majority without them.
Joint List leader Yousef Jabareen and party members celebrate the exit polls in Nazareth on Tuesday. Despite the Arab parties' record gains, the opposition refuses to recognize that it can no longer form a majority without them. Credit: Ahmad Gharabli / AFP

Israel has been plunged, once again, into political deadlock because the anti-Netanyahu opposition refused to admit – to the public and, it seems, to themselves – what ought to have been clear since 2019.

It is bad politics to promise something you cannot deliver. Now, if there is to be any hope of deposing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Gadi Eisenkot, Naftali Bennett and Avigdor Lieberman will have to violate at least one of the commitments they made during the campaign.

Breaking a central campaign promise is an inauspicious way to start things. For that reason, none of these scenarios – a minority government that includes Mansour Abbas' United Arab List and depends on the support of the Joint List, some kind of compromise with one or more of the ultra-Orthodox parties, or a combination of the two – is likely.

For all his laudable traits, Eisenkot has not shown the courage necessary to break the undemocratic norm of excluding the Arab parties from the political process. On Wednesday night, after nearly 24 hours of silence, Eisenkot announced that his party remained focused on forming a "Zionist government committed to military conscription." It is unclear what, precisely, that means, but even a broad interpretation would seem to exclude the Arab-led parties as well as the ultra-Orthodox.

The anti-Netanyahu opposition would not be in the unenviable situation in which it now finds itself had its leaders operated differently throughout the campaign: With the exception of Yair Golan, they all capitulated to Netanyahu's fear-mongering campaign against the Arab-led parties, vowing not to join with the only force that could help them defeat him

More importantly, no kind of "unity" government seems likely either. Despite enormous pressure, including, perhaps, from within his own party, Eisenkot is unlikely to opt for a national-unity government in which Netanyahu remains prime minister – Netanyahu's most basic condition, since Likud has managed to remain the largest party. Eisenkot also surely remembers what happened when Benny Gantz took his Blue and White into a Netanyahu-led unity government.

One of the ironies of the current situation is that the main reason a government backed by the Arab-led parties is being discussed at all as a possibility, however remote, is that the Israeli political terrain is polarized over Netanyahu as an individual and, to a somewhat lesser extent, the ultra-Orthodox draft issue.

That has created the opportunity for the historic reconfiguration of Israeli politics through an anti-Netanyahu coalition that relies on the Arab-led parties, a move that would not be unprecedented. In the mid-90s, Yitzhak Rabin's second government relied on outside support from Arab-led parties; more recently, in 2021, Mansour Abbas' United Arab list joined the short-lived Bennett-Lapid government to oust Netanyahu.

Still, if the opportunity is not seized now, it is unlikely to return. Were it not for the intense divisions among the Zionist-Jewish parties over Netanyahu, the right and center-right could easily form a durable coalition composed of Likud, Yashar, Together and Yisrael Beiteinu. In terms of ideology alone, there is an absolute majority for the right and center-right for the foreseeable future. Indeed, one day Netanyahu will no longer be the center of gravity of Israeli politics, which will bring its own serious challenges.

United Arab List leader Mansour Abbas, right, and fellow candidate Yoav Segalovitz in Tel Aviv last Friday. Arab-Jewish political partnership is key to an alternative government.
United Arab List leader Mansour Abbas, right, and fellow candidate Yoav Segalovitz in Tel Aviv last Friday. Arab-Jewish political partnership is key to an alternative government. Credit: David Goldman / AP Photo

In a normal, functional democracy, the resounding defeat of the incumbent coalition by a double-digit margin would lead to the formation of a new coalition. The reason this is not the case is that the votes of Israel's Arab citizens are not treated as equal to those of its Jewish citizens. But it is also true that if Netanyahu had not warped the entire political system around his persona, even the slim prospect of a minority government would not be on the agenda at all.

If there is an atmosphere of defeat among supporters of the anti-Netanyahu opposition — despite the clear majority of seats won cumulatively by parties that have repudiated the outgoing government — that is because the opposition has failed on the terms it set for itself. Its leadership refused to recognize that Israeli political reality has fundamentally changed, that the days when the secular Zionist parties of the center-right and center-left could form a majority on their own are never coming back.

Haaretz Podcast | Israel's election had no clear winner: What happens next? Aluf Benn and Esther Solomon explain

Indeed, the anti-Netanyahu opposition would not be in the unenviable situation in which it now finds itself had its leaders operated differently throughout the campaign: if, in the face of Netanyahu and his allies' attacks on the legitimacy of Arab political participation, they had insisted on the equality of all Israeli citizens and on the importance of Arab-Jewish political partnership.

Instead, they did no such thing. With the exception of Yair Golan, leader of the Democrats, they all capitulated to Netanyahu's fear-mongering campaign against the Arab-led parties. Instead of rebutting the racism of the right, they echoed it, vowing not to join with the only force in Israeli politics that could help them defeat Netanyahu and the radical, religious right.

They paid the electoral price – few right-wingers were won over to the opposition in the face of Netanyahu's attacks – but reaped none of the benefits. And in doing so, they not only defeated themselves, they also damaged the fragile remains of procedural democracy here.

Absent a minority government that depends on cooperation in some way with Mansour Abbas' United Arab List and the Joint List, the anti-Netanyahu opposition has two options, both of which will leave Netanyahu in power: either a unity government, in which Likud is the largest party, or another election, in which Netanyahu and Likud are all but guaranteed to perform better.

If, despite the clear repudiation of Netanyahu's right-wing, religious coalition, Netanyahu manages to emerge from this election still in power, the opposition will have no one to blame but themselves.



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.