[Salon] Israel’s Gridlocked Election tolls the Death Knell of Liberal Zionism




Israel’s Gridlocked Election tolls the Death Knell of Liberal Zionism

Oakland, Ca. (Special to Informed Comment; Feature) – The October 27 election in Israel was a referendum on democracy, as are the US midterms. The results of those polls are inconclusive thus far, because of the Byzantine nature of Israeli party politics and the challenge of creating a majority coalition of 61 seats, which inevitably involves making alliances with some unsavory bedfellows. Israeli President Isaac Herzog has the unenviable task of consulting with the largest coalitions to determine who gets the first shot at forming a government.

This is the most consequential task the Israeli president performs, and a huge responsibility: His first pick has 28 days to form a coalition, with a possible 14-day extension. If that fails, Herzog can appoint the other party leader with the same 28-day timeline. Failure to form a government doesn’t automatically trigger a new election, but that might well be the outcome of a deadlock. Another possibility would be for the president to allow Benjamin Netanyahu to form a caretaker government, though that step would be a Faustian bargain.

What’s bad for Israel isn’t necessarily bad for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. His selfish urgency to remain in office is dragging the nation down as never before.

The current results show the far-right wing Likud Party with 27 seats, and its projected coalition at 53. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot’s center-right Yashar Party stands at 21 seats, with his overall coalition at 48. The total seats projected to be held by the opposition parties add up to 67, a number that includes the 19 seats garnered by the Palestinian-Israeli parties of the secular Joint List headed by Yousef Jabereen, and Ra’am––the Islamically oriented United Arab List of Mansour Abbas.

The unprecedented 19 seats won by the Palestinian-Arab parties are a wild card. In most countries, that showing would make them kingmakers. They say they are willing to engage with anybody committed to Netanyahu’s ouster, but it seems improbable that Eisenkot’s coalition would be willing to allow them to join it. Prof. Juan Cole notes that the “19 seats in the 120-seat Knesset, nearly 16% of seats . . . isn’t quite equal to their 21.7% proportion of the population, but it is closer than they’ve been before.” He noted, “This rejection of political participation for over a fifth of the population illustrates the oxymoronic character of the phrase ‘Jewish and democratic.'”

Both major Zionist blocs are fractured, with tenuous, unpredictable alliances, as illustrated by the abrupt withdrawal from Eisenkot’s opposition coalition of Avigdor Lieberman, the leader of the right-wing Yisrael Beytenu (“Israel is our Home”) Party. He has cut off contact with his opposition allies, including Eisenkot and Naftali Bennett, chairman of the center-right B’Yachad (“Together”) Party. Lieberman says he wants a national unity government of Netanyahu and Eisenkot. He will not join a solely Netanyahu-led coalition, however, because of his visceral dislike for the latter.

If the two Zionist blocs refuse to form a national unity government, the numbers dictate that neither alone can put together a government without the Palestinian-Israeli parties. Given the revulsion against this idea expressed by Eisenkot, by Lieberman, and by Bennett, it seems most unlikely that the opposition will bring the Joint List and Ra’am aboard.  

If Netanyahu prevails, it will be due to the demographics of the Haredim and religious parties, who tend to have very large families. Netanyahu enjoys overwhelming support in those Ultra-Orthodox towns, kibbutzim and neighborhoods. This popularity arises from his record of doing their political bidding, along with religious considerations.  “Haredi” is derived from the Hebrew word meaning “to tremble,” as in trembling from fear of God. Their unwavering support for Netanyahu makes me tremble.

Eisenkot favors ending the draft exemption for Haredi young men, which makes them tremble. He also wants to keep all legal West Bank settlements in place and secure, but wants to dismantle the illegal ones. The International Court of Justice, however, has ruled that all Israeli squatting on the land of the Palestinian West Bank is illegal in international law.




This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.