[Salon] Fwd: Haaretz, Leon Hadar: "American Jews Are Quietly Divorcing the Zionist Consensus." (11/02/26)




American Jews Are Quietly Divorcing the Zionist Consensus

Leon Hadar • November 02 2026 
American Jews at a conference by JStreet, a liberal lobby on Israel-Palestine policy.
American Jews at a conference by JStreet, a liberal lobby on Israel-Palestine policy. Credit: Gili Getz

A growing number of American Jews no longer identify with Zionism, and the old assumption that Jewish identity demands loyalty to Israel's government is coming apart

For most of the past half-century, the leaders of American Jewish organizations operated on an assumption so obvious that it hardly needed stating. To be a Jew in America was to be a supporter of Israel, and to be a supporter of Israel was to support whatever government happened to sit in Jerusalem. Dissent was treated as a family embarrassment, to be handled behind closed doors, not aired on the op-ed page of The New York Times.

That assumption is now collapsing. The collapse is not coming in the dramatic fashion imagined by the pro-Israel establishment, with a sudden defection to the barricades of anti-Zionism. It is coming the way most historical shifts do: slowly, unevenly and then all at once.

Consider the numbers. On the surface, the old consensus looks intact. An overwhelming 86 percent of American Jews identify as pro-Israel, including 65 percent who say they are pro-Israel but critical of some or many Israeli government policies. Yet the poll also found that 61 percent view Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu unfavorably. And when the topic shifts from Israel to Zionism, something revealing happens. Most respondents view Zionism as Jewish self-determination, yet only one-third call themselves Zionists.

Think about that for a moment. A community that funds, lobbies for and emotionally invests in the Jewish state no longer wishes to wear the label of the movement that created it. That is not a policy disagreement, it is an identity shift.

The generational data is starker still. Almost half of American Jews under 35 now say the conflict should be resolved through a single state spanning Israel, the West Bank and Gaza, with a government elected by both Israelis and Palestinians. That is the binational idea Judah Magnes and Martin Buber once championed and that mainstream Zionism spent a century dismissing as naive or worse. Only four years ago, an American Jewish Committee survey found 23 percent of Jews ages 25- 40 supporting a binational state. Whatever one thinks of the idea on its merits, a doubling in four years is not noise.

The Israeli right and its American allies will blame all of this on campus radicals, TikTok and the corrosive influence of "woke" ideology. That explanation is comforting, and it is mostly wrong. The more interesting story is that American Jews are returning to a much older tradition, one that predates the Six-Day War and the institutional Zionism that followed it.

Pro-Palestinian protesters at Harvard University, October 14, 2023
Pro-Palestinian protesters at Harvard University, October 14, 2023 Credit: Joseph Prezioso / AFP

It is worth recalling that the founders of American Reform Judaism declared, in the 1885 Pittsburgh Platform, that Jews were no longer a nation but a religious community, and that they expected no return to Palestine. Well into the 1940s, a significant portion of the American Jewish elite regarded political Zionism with suspicion, as a European answer to a European problem. Their homeland was America. Their Judaism was an ethical and religious inheritance, not a claim on territory.

What changed was 1967. The lightning victory transformed Israel from a fragile refuge into a source of pride and, eventually, into the organizing principle of American Jewish civic life. Federations, lobbies and summer trips replaced synagogue attendance and Hebrew literacy as the markers of belonging. Israel became, in effect, the civil religion of a community that was steadily losing its actual religion.

That arrangement was always a marriage of convenience. It worked as long as Israel could be imagined as a liberal democracy under siege, a Middle Eastern version of the progressive values most American Jews held at home. It began fraying when Israeli politics moved decisively to the right, with a governing coalition whose ministers openly advocate annexation and whose worldview has far more in common with Christian evangelicals in Texas than with Reform congregants in Westchester.

The Gaza war turned the fraying into a tear. A Washington Post poll found that 61 percent of Jewish adults said Israel had committed war crimes against Palestinians in Gaza; 39 percent said it was guilty of genocide. Those are not the attitudes of a community prepared to follow Jerusalem's lead.

Palestinians walk past the rubble of residential buildings destroyed during the war, in Gaza City, August 2026.
Palestinians walk past the rubble of residential buildings destroyed during the war, in Gaza City, August 2026. Credit: Mahmoud Issa/ REUTERS

Last week's election appears unlikely to affect this, especially considering that Netanyahu seems poised to continue occupying a leading position, either as head of a minority government or as member of a national unity government.

There is an irony here that ought to be savored. For decades, Israeli leaders from David Ben-Gurion on treated the Diaspora as a temporary condition, a way station on the road to aliyah. American Jews were expected to send money, political support and, ideally, their children, and little else. Now American Jews are taking the Zionist premise seriously in a way its authors never intended. If Israel is a sovereign state like any other, then it can be judged like any other. It is no longer the collective property of world Jewry, to be defended regardless of what it does.

For U.S. foreign policy, this matters more than Washington has yet grasped. The "special relationship" has rested on a domestic political coalition in which American Jews provided much of the intellectual and organizational energy and evangelical Protestants provided the votes. Remove the first pillar, or even merely weaken it, and the relationship begins to look like what realists always said it was: an alliance with a small, prosperous regional power whose interests sometimes coincide with America's and sometimes do not. It deserves the same cost-benefit scrutiny Washington applies to Turkey or Saudi Arabia.

The partisan contours are already visible. Most Jewish Democrats support cutting aid to Israel, while majorities of Jewish independents and Republicans oppose it. The pro-Israel coalition is becoming a Republican coalition, and a coalition that depends on one party is a coalition living on borrowed time. None of this means American Jews are abandoning Israel, let alone their Jewishness. What is happening is closer to a normalization: a shift from a relationship of fealty to one of affinity, the way Irish Americans feel about Dublin or Greek Americans about Athens. They care, they visit, they argue, but they do not confuse their identity with the policies of a foreign government.

The establishment organizations, still insisting that criticism of Zionism is tantamount to antisemitism, are fighting the last war. They may find, a decade from now, that they have preserved their institutions and lost their constituents. The quiet divorce will not be announced. It will simply be noticed, one day, that the couple has been living apart for years.

Leon Hadar, a Washington-based journalist and political scientist, is a senior fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute.



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.