[Salon] Edward Said / Palestine: We Should Have Listened




Mezze - المزة - a wide selection of small dishes served as appetizers, including such delicacies as hummus, cheese, eggplant, brains, stuffed grape leaves, calamari, and much more
͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­
Forwarded this email? Subscribe here for more

Monday Mezze: Edward Said / Palestine: We Should Have Listened

Mezze - المزة - a wide selection of small dishes served as appetizers, including such delicacies as hummus, cheese, eggplant, brains, stuffed grape leaves, calamari, and much more

Nov 2
 
READ IN APP
 

Good morning Family, Friends, and Colleagues,

The midterms are upon us. Millions of Americans have already voted and tomorrow, on Tuesday, November 3rd, final ballots will be cast.

Personally, I am fearful, not just about what the results may augur for the future of American Democracy in its 250th year but what - on a more personal level - it will reveal about our electorate, about which values we believe American society should hold as one, about what it will reveal about American society as a whole.

Today, as an Arab-American-Muslim, I am outraged not just about the pernicious and racist rise in Islamophobia - and the fearless way people are willing to flaunt their hatred and prejudices - but also about the witnessing of political and cultural abuse - so dangerously and casually tolerated - of fellow citizens like Zohran Mamdani, Abdul El-Sayed, and Ilhan Omar - Americans all who are living from sea to shining sea who shouldn’t have to be waiting for good samaritans to recognize and rescue them and their families before the aspirational promises of our Founding Fathers expire, failing them, failing America.

One day to go.
Pray.

Salamaat,
Robert

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Edward Said / Palestine: We Should Have Listened

Edward Said was born in British-Mandate Palestine in 1935.

Yesterday was his birthday. Had he survived his 12-year struggle with chronic lymphocytic leukemia he would at this moment be celebrating 90 years of scholarship, activism, and creativity, most of which had been lived under Al-Nakba - the Catastrophe - a time measured from 1948 to the present day of ongoing violent displacement, occupation, dispossession, and ethnic cleansing of hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs from the creation of the State of Israel to this moment.

Photograph © Robert Azzi 2026. All Rights Reserved.

I first met Said in 1975- a Jerusalem-born Palestinian-American who was University Professor of English and Comparative Literature at Columbia University. It was at the home of a colleague, James Markham, then the New York Times bureau chief in Lebanon - three years before Orientalism was published - that our paths crossed.

Three years before he revolutionized the world of post-colonial studies.

As Edward Said explained in Orientalism in 1978, “From the beginning of Western speculation about the Orient, the one thing the orient could not do was to represent itself. Evidence of the Orient was credible only after it had passed through and been made firm by the refining fire of the Orientalist’s work.”

Edward focused our attention on the fact that the West demands we ask permission to narrate - I believe we still do.

Orientalism, and all of Edward’s work that followed - plus his friendship - over the years gave me perspective and language to understand what I myself, as a Beirut-based photojournalist covering the Middle East and North Africa, was encountering and struggling against - encounters with The West that tried to make less credible the work I was doing.

A particularly painful encounter was a struggle over erasure with National Geographic Magazine over an article I photographed and wrote on Damascus [Syria] which they published in 1974 - an article which they, yielding to pro-Israeli pressure, then partly retracted.*

I was right - they were wrong.

Sadly, such encounters persist to the current moment.

I’ve been thinking a lot about Edward lately - as faithful readers will recognize from previous posts - especially as I read this week that Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territory occupied since 1967, presented a report to the UN General Assembly that reads in part:**

“The killing of Palestinian journalists, Israel’s control of information and distorted coverage by influential Western media and digital platforms form one system that has enabled genocide in Gaza and shielded it from scrutiny.”

“Genocide is never sustained by killing alone. It requires destroying the conditions in which killing can be seen, documented, remembered and judged,” she said. “Israel has eliminated the witnesses, controlled the information, incited hatred and relied on others to repeat its story. The result is what I call ‘mediacide:’ the systematic destruction of the media’s public function.”

As a journalist I have been taking all this really personally, especially as I, Nieman Fellow ‘77, feel that Harvard’s Nieman Foundation for Journalism - as well as other journalistic associations - has been complicit in “shielding” [the true nature of genocide and journalist deaths] in Gaza from scrutiny.”

Which I believe makes them complicit in acts of genocide.

Such testimony as Albanese’s only reinforces what Said and other scholars have long argued - that local testimonies, stories, histories, and self-portrayals have historically been judged invalid or uncredible by The West until they were filtered, translated, and validated through Western scholarship.

This dynamic also allows Western powers - still - to sustain a controlled, romanticized, or backward image of “the Orient” that it used to justify colonial rule and cultural superiority, from arguing that “Palestine was a land without a people for a people without a land,” through coordinated and criminal denials and suppression of the facts that Israel today is guilty of apartheid and ethnic cleansing and is committing genocide - still - against the Palestinian people.

In 2003, just months before he died, and as George W. Bush was invading Iraq and breaking the Middle East in irreparable ways, Edward Said wrote a new preface for the Twenty-Fifth Anniversary Edition of Orientalism, in which he wrote, “It is quite common to hear high officials in Washington and elsewhere speak of changing the map of the Middle East, as if ancient societies and myriad peoples can be shaken up like so many peanuts in a jar.”

How unbearably prescient, how incalculably tragic that so few listened.

One of the last times I spoke to Edward was during the winter of 2001/02. He called out of the blue late one evening and after a couple brief pleasantries said “ ... Azzi ... I know your daughter is applying to Columbia [as a freshman] probably with hope - her father’s hopes probably ... that I would be here to mentor her ... I’m calling to tell you please don’t count on me ... I probably won’t make it ... and she probably doesn’t need me anyway ...”

Edward died September 2003.

We all needed Edward.

We still do.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

* Read pages 304-306: https://eaford.org/site/assets/files/1023/they_dare_to_speak_out_paul_findley.pdf
* https://avalonlibrary.net/National_Geographic/National%20Geographic%201974-11%20146-5%20Nov.pdf
** https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2026/10/israels-war-journalists-war-truth-itself-un-expert-tells-general-assembly

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

It’s a difficult time, my loved ones.
Draw your keffiyeh close.
Stand Strong.
RESIST.

Salamaat,
Robert



Robert Azzi / The Other is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

You're currently a free subscriber to Robert Azzi / The Other . For the full experience, upgrade your subscription.

Upgrade to paid

 
Share
 
 
Like
Comment
Restack
 

© 2026 Robert Azzi / The Other
548 Market Street PMB 72296, San Francisco, CA 94104
Unsubscribe

Start your Substack



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.