[Salon] Most American Jews Voted Democratic Again. So Why Did 2026 Feel Different?




11/4/26

Most American Jews Voted Democratic Again. So Why Did 2026 Feel Different? - Haaretz Today

Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed shakes hands with supporters after declaring victory in Michigan's race, Tuesday.
Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed shakes hands with supporters after declaring victory in Michigan's race, Tuesday. Credit: Jeff Kowalsky/AFP

In the days leading up to the election, Jewish leaders, newspaper headlines and even President Donald Trump warned of a potential earthquake in American Jewish politics. Growing opposition to Israel among Democrats, including among a wave of far-left candidates, could cause Jews to abandon the Democratic Party.

That didn't happen, according to early data from Election Day. An exit poll of 100,000 voters conducted on behalf of major news networks by SSRS found that 67 percent of Jewish voters backed Democratic candidates on Tuesday – in line with their historical voting patterns, including in the 2024 presidential election.

Exit polls can be unreliable. But this one found that, again, Jews were among the most thoroughly Democratic constituencies, though this year they were outpaced among religious groups by Muslims. Eighty-five percent of Muslim voters opted for Democrats, according to the poll.

A second poll, conducted by GBAO Strategies for the liberal pro-Israel group J Street, found that 72 percent of Jews voted for Democrats.

"The much-discussed, so-called 'exodus' of Jewish voters from the Democratic Party once again hasn't materialized," J Street CEO Jeremy Ben-Ami tweeted on Tuesday night.

"Predictions of Jewish Americans leaving the Dem Party were grossly overstated," Halie Soifer, CEO of the Jewish Democratic Council of America, wrote on X on Tuesday night. "Jewish voters despise Trump & the GOP he controls."

The polls suggest that Jewish voters did not play a role in the surge that Democrats experienced across much of the country. The two thirds who backed Democratic candidates were roughly the same share that backed Kamala Harris in 2024, according to AP VoteCast. The J Street survey also found that Jews voted for Democrats at the same rate as in 2024.

In Michigan, some Jewish leaders openly opposed the Democratic Senate candidate, Abdul El-Sayed, yet there is still little evidence of a major shift. An exit poll of early voters conducted on behalf of the Jewish Majority, a group founded to oppose anti-Zionism in politics, found that 57 percent favored El-Sayed – far less than the 79 percent backing Democrat Jocelyn Benson for governor.

Because that survey looked at only voters motivated enough to cast their ballots before Election Day, it's possible that Jews in Michigan ultimately voted for El-Sayed at a higher rate.

But topline numbers suggesting an enduring Jewish Democratic consensus fail to capture the significance of the sturm and drang that preceded Election Day, and the complicated feelings that many Jewish voters brought into the ballot box.

Some voters who took equally seriously their commitments as Americans and as Jews struggled at times to reconcile them. And even some Jewish Democrats who believe the U.S.-Israel relationship is due for revision experienced the intensity of criticism of Israel and its supporters from some Democratic candidates as uncomfortable at best and antisemitic at worst.

Many felt ignored by politicians, pundits and a populace that seemed to dismiss their concerns too easily. Even as they are relieved that Democrats took the House and Senate, they remain concerned about the presence of Hasan Piker, the streamer who has said Zionists should be treated as neo-Nazis, at the center of the party's left wing. On Tuesday night, Piker hosted a livestream promoted by the Democratic Socialists of America, which had several of its members elected to Congress.

The exit polls suggest that in a binary system, the Jewish vote is stable. But in the world outside the ballot box, where complexity reigns, American Jews have feelings that are all over the place. Their leaders might consider shifting now from politics to the pastoral care their communities need to enter this new era with confidence and resilience, ready to weather whatever the lawmakers they helped elect may say or do – about Israel or anything else.



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.