The Democratic Party's capture of the U.S. Senate and the House of Representatives marks the beginning of the translation into policy of the massive shift in opinion on Israel.
Israeli leaders have shown little indication that they are ready for this moment, nor have they begun to prepare the people for what these shifts could mean for their lives. Instead, in what may be his final months as prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu has ushered Israelis further into the burrow of denial.
Faced with the prospect of restrictions on weapons supplies, if not outright embargoes, he has propounded the bellicose delusion of Israel as a "super Sparta," an autarkic garrison state on the model of Pyongyang. In response to fears that sanctions could cripple the country's banking system, he has told the people not to worry and instead put their trust in cryptocurrencies, a practice common to terror groups like the Islamic State and Hezbollah.
At risk for Israel is the integration of its banking system with the rest of the world, the solvency of its economy, and perhaps most frightening, the U.S. military umbrella.
On the whole, Israelis do not grasp the magnitude of the change that the midterm results portend.
For more than 30 years, they have grown accustomed to enjoying the fruits of their country's integration into the global market economy – visa-free travel to Europe, the full menu of consumer goods, foreign investment in high-tech startups and companies, and the most advanced U.S. military technology bought at a discount. Israel's period of profound isolation and economic stagnation, when it was truly a Spartan holdout on the eastern Mediterranean, is for most Israelis a distant memory or piece of history.
Yet now, largely due to the wars in Gaza and Iran, much of what Israelis take for granted may well be cast into doubt: the integration of its banking system with the rest of the world, the solvency of its economy, and perhaps most frightening, the U.S. military umbrella.
The Israeli media has played its part in shielding Israelis from this reality. It has dwelled on the most extreme statements, of which there has been no shortage, expressed by some of the newly elected U.S. senators and representatives.
Yet largely unmentioned on mainstream television, to say nothing of Channel 14, Israel's gonzo Fox News parallel, is what Israel has done to generate the outrage that helped power insurgent candidates to victory. The list includes the destruction of Gaza; the killing of more than 70,000 people, most of them civilians; the gruesome restriction of humanitarian aid; and perhaps most consequential, the debacle of the unfinished, humiliating war with Iran.
There is no question that antisemitism has become part of U.S. politics to an extent previously unimaginable. But the tectonic shift in U.S. opinion on Israel, solidified by the makeup of the incoming Congress, cannot be written off as a paroxysm of anti-Jewish animus.
For every radical ideologically committed to Israel's demise, there are several moderates willing to accept and even back Israel's continued existence, provided it complies with international law and human rights statutes. At the same time, if Israel's next government does not change course, even moderate U.S. Democrats will likely join the hard-liners in supporting unprecedented measures against Israel.
A change in the Israeli leadership will not be enough to arrest the gathering tide. The debate in the United States has swung so much that the central question is no longer whether the U.S.-Israel relationship should be reformulated, but how severe the steps should be for punishing Israel for its wrongdoing. Such steps include possible conditions on arms or even a total embargo; a possible settlement boycott or even large-scale sanctions.
No amount of revamped hasbara, high-tech influence campaigns or even more measured rhetoric – what opposition leaders like Yair Lapid and Naftali Bennett have promised – will adequately address that. Only dramatic, concrete shifts in policy will.
Another Netanyahu-led government is almost guaranteed to accelerate the process toward substantive punitive steps against Israel. And while a Prime Minister Gadi Eisenkot, perhaps leading a government supported in some way by the Arab-led parties, may get the benefit of the doubt for a time, the first instance of West Bank settler violence or an airstrike killing dozens in Gaza will be a test that he, and the country, cannot afford to fail.
The Americans will be watching. An Eisenkot government, and in a sense the country's future, will be judged by whether his cabinet holds the people who carry out such actions accountable, or if impunity will remain the norm.
No opposition leader during the campaign – save, at times, for Democrats leader Yair Golan – had the courage to connect the collapse of Israel's standing to the way it has waged its wars against its neighbors and in the region. Through their relative silence on these matters, Lapid, Bennett and Eisenkot have acted as inadvertent auxiliaries to Netanyahu's efforts to sever Israelis from the geopolitical reality. If they somehow manage to come to power, they will have to pull the people, and perhaps even themselves, out of their profound state of denial. That is no small task.
For now, at least, Trump has two more years in which he can veto Democrats' initiatives, and in any event, foreign policy is to a large degree insulated from democratic disputation. But the dramatic recomposition of Congress is a clear indication of the direction that U.S. policy on Israel is likely to take once Trump is gone. Israelis are not ready.