Trump’s deference to Israel and war on Iran cost Republicans control of Congress. With JD Vance already distancing himself from both, Democrats may find themselves vulnerable over Ukraine.
On the morning after Democrats’ historic victory in Tuesday’s midterm elections, Vice President JD Vance offered a blunt post-mortem of his party’s failure: “The reason we lost is the war.” Vance pointed out that while 2024 Republican voters showed up to the polls, they did so this time to rebuke the White House. Betraying a promise of no new wars, Donald Trump launched a regime change war on Iran that has spiked the cost of living. Citing his own pollsters, Vance additionally acknowledged that voters would like the US to “change our relationship to Israel,” a state that commits live-streamed mass murder in Gaza, lobbied for the Iran war, and plays a toxic role in US political life. Vance is trying to save his 2028 presidential ambitions from an unpopular war of aggression that he himself has defended, despite his own reported misgivings from the start. If Democrats wish to continue their winning streak, the vice-president’s public effort at damage control, however cynical, is not to be dismissed. The Middle East is not the only war zone disrupting the global economy and fueling populist resentment. The other is the proxy war in Ukraine, a signature Biden policy that Democrats across the spectrum have embraced. Vance, by contrast, has positioned himself as a skeptic of that conflict and a driver of the administration’s bid to bring it to a negotiated end. Trump might still double down on his anti-war betrayal and relaunch the Iran war to even more devastating effect. Yet if he can manage to cut his losses in Iran, and follow through on a peace deal in Ukraine, Democrats may find themselves in a vulnerable position. The danger is not that Ukraine will cost Democrats at the pump the way Iran cost Republicans, but that they will cede the anti-war lane to Vance just as they twice did to Trump. No other foreign conflict of the post-9/11 era has seen Democratic lawmakers so uniformly hawkish or so far to the right of their Republican rivals. In the five spending packages passed after Russia’s February 2022 invasion—totaling roughly $175 billion—not a single Democrat in either chamber cast a direct vote against Ukraine military aid. (The handful of Democratic no votes were protests against the Israel aid bundled into the same bills.) Trump’s recent break with Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky, easing of Russia sanctions, and embrace of diplomacy with Moscow have only elicited more Democratic belligerence. Last month, Democratic Senator Chris Murphy declared that “Ukraine was winning the war, so Trump kneecapped Ukraine to help Russia.” Murphy even recycled Russiagate by speculating that Putin had “called in a favor, using whatever leverage he has over the President.” Hillary Clinton also rehashed the Trump-Russia collusion tale that her campaign generated. Trump, she declared, is a “willing Putin puppet,” and “I continue to believe that Putin has things on Trump... photos, videos, whatever it might be.” Along with reviving their discredited conspiracy theory, Russia-baiting Democrats are overlooking the lessons of their electoral losses to Trump. In 2016, the Republican candidate won over a significant portion of voters by claiming to oppose bipartisan militarism. After the Biden administration fueled both the proxy war in Ukraine and the Gaza genocide, Trump took full advantage in 2024 by running as the “peace” candidate. Whereas Vance now attempts to lay claim to the anti-war mantle inside his party on Iran, Ukraine, and even Israel, no major Democratic politician can say the same. Sensing the political shift among their voting base, many Democratic lawmakers have renounced Israel and its powerful lobbying apparatus. There has been no such shift on Ukraine. The last time anyone tried was right before the previous midterms. In October 2022, a faction of the progressive caucus called on President Biden to negotiate with Russia to end the Ukraine war. The polite request did not even hint at cutting off future war funding, nor reference the multiple diplomatic opportunities that the Biden team had already sabotaged, including the Istanbul talks of earlier that year. Despite the letter’s muted tone, a torrent of Beltway outrage forced a retraction within 24 hours. Even the progressive standard-bearer, Bernie Sanders, rejected the pro-diplomacy initiative and welcomed its retraction. Joining the chorus of naysayers, Sanders’ longtime foreign policy advisor, Matt Duss, argued that it was worth continuing the proxy war despite its contravention of a basic progressive value: “[T]he policy I support continues to enrich defense contractors, enriches the military-industrial complex . . . the policy I support in the shorter term is essentially paying them off.” Four years later, that policy has helped bring devastation to Ukraine and turmoil to the global economy. If progressive proxy warriors continue to pay off the military-industrial complex in the name of Ukraine, they will not only write off their commitment to peace, but their appeal to war-weary voters. Amid forty-year-high inflation during his presidency, Biden deflected criticism on the Ukraine war by blaming what he called “Putin’s Price Hike” and arguing that “defending freedom is going to cost.” Asked to address families who could not afford rising gas prices, Biden’s top economic advisor, Brian Deese, responded: “This is about the future of the liberal world order and we have to stand firm.” Trump, in his cavalier arrogance, has similarly dismissed complaints about the Iran war’s domestic costs by mocking the concept of affordability, lying about stopping a fictional Iranian nuclear weapons program, and spreading blatant Islamophobia, foremost against Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed. Trump’s abandonment of his own anti-interventionist pledges helped cost Republicans a midterm election. If Democrats cannot apply that lesson to their signature proxy war in Ukraine, they may find themselves on the losing end of the next anti-war wave. This post is only for paid subscribers of Aaron Mate. |