[Salon] Ukraine Caused 3 in 4 Verified Donbas Civilian Deaths Before the War



Forwarded this email? Subscribe here for more

Ukraine Caused 3 in 4 Verified Donbas Civilian Deaths Before the War

Conversation with former OSCE Monitor, Benoît Paré

Nov 7
 
READ IN APP
 

For seven years, Benoît Paré worked as a civilian monitor with the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission in Ukraine. Deployed between 2015 and 2022, he served on both sides of the contact line in Donbas, first in the Human Dimension unit responsible for verifying civilian casualties and human-rights issues, and later in other roles. In a detailed conversation with, he describes a mission that, in his view, regularly and deliberately covered up the scale of civilian casualties caused by Ukraine.

The Peacemonger is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Paré explains that the OSCE developed a rigorous methodology for confirming civilian casualties, requiring three independent sources: medical records, official confirmation from local authorities or police, and verification from the victim or their family.

Using this standard, he and colleagues compiled data showing that the majority of verified casualties from shelling and shooting occurred on the non-government-controlled - i.e. separatist - side. In the figures published for 2016, 63 percent of civilian casualties were recorded in separatist-held areas. Paré’s own longer-term analysis, covering 2016–2018 across both oblasts, put the figure at roughly 72 percent—nearly three out of four. In Mariupol in 2018 the imbalance for shelling and shooting reached 90 percent. These numbers, he argues, directly contradicted the dominant narrative that Ukrainian forces almost never initiated fire and that civilian suffering was overwhelmingly caused by the other side.

According to Paré, this data created political problems. After the 2016 figures were published, the Ukrainian delegation objected strongly and accused the mission of being manipulated by Russian monitors. From that point, the OSCE ceased publishing disaggregated casualty statistics by side, even though the internal database continued to be updated. Paré says he prepared tables showing the trends and sent them up the chain of command, including a formal memo to the Head of Mission proposing that the figures be made public. He received no reply.

He also recounts specific cases in which patrol reports were altered before publication. In one instance, damage observed on the non-government-controlled side was presented in the official report as occurring on the government-controlled side. In another, a monitor who heard gunshots but could not determine their origin later found the published report attributing the fire to the separatist side.

Paré notes that one of the individuals involved in daily reporting had previously worked for the National Endowment for Democracy in Ukraine, and that another person in a sensitive reporting role in headquarters was reportedly in a relationship with an SBU lieutenant colonel. Interpreters whose spouses worked for the SBU were also used on sensitive interviews. Meanwhile, he says, monitors perceived as too close to the separatist side had their contracts terminated, creating what he describes as a clear double standard.

Paré eventually resigned, returned briefly for election observation in Lviv, and later served again in Odessa, where he observed the effects of language laws on Russian-speaking communities. He has since published his account as What I Saw in Ukraine 2015-2022: Journal of an International Observer, which includes the memo he sent to mission leadership and further documentation of the issues discussed in the interview.

Share

The full conversation covers the casualty methodology, the examples of report alteration, the internal culture of the mission, and Paré’s experiences in different regions of Ukraine. You can watch it here:

Benoît Paré’s book is available at https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/295986011X. He can be found on X at @BenoitPare_Obs and on Substack at https://substack.com/@benoitpare.

Wherever you are in the world, whatever your nationality and religion, I wish you much peace.

You're currently a free subscriber to The Peacemonger. For the full experience, upgrade your subscription.

Upgrade to paid

 
Like
Comment
Restack
 

© 2026 ian
548 Market Street PMB 72296, San Francisco, CA 94104
Unsubscribe

Start your Substack



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.