[Salon] Israel Needs an Abdul El-Sayed of Its Own




Israel Needs an Abdul El-Sayed of Its Own

Gideon Levy • November 08 2026
Michigan Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed speaks at an election night event early Wednesday in Detroit, as his wife Sarah Jukaku watches.
Michigan Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed speaks at an election night event early Wednesday in Detroit, as his wife Sarah Jukaku watches. Credit: Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP 

The normalization of both Muslims and socialist leftists, who are elected despite their identity rather than because of it, is still foreign to Israel

"JD, habibi, there is this delicious irony in the fact that you're constitutionally obligated to swear me in in January." I've watched Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan over and over as he gleefully needles Vice President JD Vance, who in the past has called him "a little weasel," "very, very evil" and "a little bit of a psychopath." And I melted with pleasure.

And how pleasurable it was to watch him similarly needle Donald Trump, saying that he had noticed that the U.S. president had trouble pronouncing his first name – Abdulrahman – and telling him that after he is sworn in, "you could just go on and call me Senator." A star is born, perhaps the next Barack Obama. They are made of similar stuff.

In paranoid, provincial Israel, the election of El-Sayed was portrayed as a victory for the devil, almost an existential threat. After all, he hates Israel and is an antisemite to boot. But in more enlightened places, his election was seen as renewed proof that the United States is the land of unlimited possibility. 

El-Sayed's victory and the achievements of other progressive candidates make America great again. It's heartbreaking for the MAGA crowd. But it bodes well for America, for the world and, on good days, for Israel as well.

A drone view of an election billboard by Benjamin Netanyahu's Likud Party depicting Iran's Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan and Hezbollah chief Naim Qassem and a text in Hebrew that reads "They Want Netanyahu to Lose, Don't let them Win", in Tel Aviv, Israel in August.
A drone view of an election billboard by Benjamin Netanyahu's Likud Party depicting Iran's Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan and Hezbollah chief Naim Qassem and a text in Hebrew that reads "They Want Netanyahu to Lose, Don't let them Win", in Tel Aviv, Israel in August. Credit: Amir Cohen/Reuters

It's impossible not to be impressed by El-Sayed's personal charm, his charisma, his humor, his warmth and his enormous self-confidence. Sometimes it's good to see a Muslim, a child of Arab immigrants – a "minority member," as he would be called in Israel – respond with braggadocio to the white majority. In Israel, that hasn't yet happened. The Israeli El-Sayed hasn't yet been born.

The population of Michigan, the state that is sending him to the Senate, is about 10 million, similar to that of Israel. Only 3 to 4 percent of Michigan's population is of Arab origin.

Consequently, there's no point in trying to paint the Arab minority as the source of support for this rising star, a physician and a child of immigrants who grew up in Alexandria, Egypt. Michigan's vote for El-Sayed was unrelated to his ethnic origin, just as New York City's vote for Zohran Mamdani was unrelated to his religion.

This is the point that we Israelis should be jealous of – the normalization of both Muslims and socialist leftists, who are elected despite their identity rather than because of it. That is something foreign to Israel. 

Here, Arabs are indeed elected, but none of them are elected despite their identity. Just imagine an Arab being elected as mayor of Tel Aviv-Jaffa, and not just with the votes of residents of Jaffa, but with the votes of a majority of Tel Aviv's residents. That has never happened, and it presumably never will.

People watch election returns before Michigan Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed arrives at a Michigan Democratic Party election night event, Tuesday.
People watch election returns before Michigan Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed arrives at a Michigan Democratic Party election night event, Tuesday. Credit: Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP 

It's true that the Jewish-Arab relationship in Israel is different from the relationship between Americans who were born there and immigrants. Nevertheless, the phenomenon of Mamdani and El-Sayed fires the imagination. 

After being elected, El-Sayed explained his attitude toward Israel and Jews. On the "Morning Joe" news talk show and podcast, he said he grew up with Jews, went to bar- and bat-mitzvah parties and learned to admire the Jewish religion and Jews' contribution to America.

His harsh criticism of Israel's government doesn't stem from hatred of Jews. He and others like him simply object to funding a country that commits war crimes, he said. And that position is admirable. 

Once, when asked about a two-state solution, he responded by asking how exactly a Palestinian state would be established. There are Israelis who ask exactly the same question. 

Mamdani and El-Sayed are the promising new face of America. They are young, left-wing men of conscience, and they won't agree to let America continue funding Israel's wars of choice. The pro-Israel lobby AIPAC spent around $30 million to prevent El-Sayed from being chosen as the Democratic Party's candidate, but he beat a friend of Israel, Rep. Haley Stevens, in the primary.

In the light of the embarrassing interviews she gave after her failure, my joy over El-Sayed's election is even greater. Yes, even an Israeli is allowed to rejoice at the election of an impressive, principled man who belongs to a minority group and is even a Muslim.

Ya habibi, Abdulrahman El-Sayed. Congratulations from Israel, too.




This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.