The United States faces an increasingly difficult position in its confrontation with Iran, Iranian Professor Mohammad Marandi said, arguing that President Donald Trump must choose between accepting Tehran's demands and escalating a war that could carry devastating consequences for Washington and the global economy.
Speaking on Al Mayadeen's The Grand Standoff: Iran and the World, Marandi said Trump's political standing and that of the Republican Party suffered considerable damage, while the latest electoral developments in the United States further complicated the president's position. Nevertheless, he warned against expecting Trump to change course, pointing to his political calculations and the composition of his administration.
Marandi stated that Trump had inflicted damage on himself and his party on a scale not seen in American politics for decades. He added that the president's choice of senior personnel suggested he intended to double down rather than reconsider his approach.
Washington now faces two possible paths: backing down and easing tensions with Tehran, or launching another military assault, he outlined. Neither option offers an easy way out, particularly as maritime attacks and mounting economic pressures threaten to deepen the crisis.
"The status quo is not sustainable because everyday ships are being destroyed, the markets are in trouble, and this is going to lead to catastrophic consequences for the global economy and for US proxies in the region," he said.
A further US assault, Marandi warned, would be even more damaging for Washington, given Iran's capacity to respond. He also questioned the administration's decision-making, arguing that the current White House has demonstrated a greater degree of irrationality toward Iran than previous administrations over several decades.
Marandi argued that Trump has limited time to reconsider his position, particularly as pressure is expected to intensify once the new US Congress begins its work. Developments surrounding the leadership of the Israeli regime could further complicate Washington's calculations, he added.
For Tehran, however, neither changes in the US administration nor developments in the Israeli political establishment alter its position. Marandi stressed that Iran's objective remains a just peace, which requires Washington to meet Tehran's seven demands and implement the memorandum of understanding (MoU).
"If Trump is pushed to accept those conditions now, hypothetically speaking, it doesn't make a difference to Iran. Iran is prepared to move forward now. If he is unprepared to do that, Iran will continue to put pressure on the United States until the United States does accept Iran's demands," he explained.
He maintained that Washington had previously had an opportunity to reach an understanding with Tehran before the elections, arguing that accepting the MoU at that stage could have spared Trump a more damaging political defeat.
"In fact, if Trump was sane enough, if he was wise enough to accept the MOU a few weeks ago, perhaps his defeat wouldn't have been so bad."
Iran, he said, would have been prepared to move forward had the United States implemented its commitments.
Meanwhile, Tehran's maritime strategy remains central to its efforts to maintain pressure on Washington. Marandi said Iran continues to strike ships linked to US-affiliated regimes in the region that had assisted Washington against Iran and refused to comply with instructions from the Iranian armed forces.
The objective, he explained, is to increase the economic costs of the confrontation and make the existing situation increasingly difficult for Washington to sustain. Each additional attack on shipping compounds the pressure on international markets and the US economy.
Drawing a parallel between Washington's economic warfare against Iran and Tehran's response, Marandi stressed that Iran had been more successful in using economic pressure to pursue political objectives.
"The United States tried to bring about regime change through economic warfare. The Iranians did the same to the United States, and the Iranians have had far more success than the Americans," he said, adding that Tehran would continue pursuing this policy.
Marandi also expected further attacks on shipping in the Strait of Hormuz, arguing that Iran would maintain its pressure until Washington made a decision between backing down and escalating the confrontation.
"I think we will see ships struck in the Strait of Hormuz in the days ahead. It will continue until, as your good guest in the United States points out, the United States makes a decision, because this is not sustainable," he said.
He warned that the consequences would extend well beyond the immediate confrontation, pointing to the growing pressure on shipping capacity and energy prices.
"Every day that goes by and Iran hits more ships, we are – the world is heading towards a crisis. A shortage of ships is going – is clearly something that the world will face down the road. And of course, the high price in energy is not sustainable for the global economy," Marandi said.
He added that Iran would continue tightening the pressure through the Strait of Hormuz even if Washington refrained from launching another assault, seeking to compel the United States to either abandon its current approach or escalate the war.
Turning to the US political landscape, the Iranian academic cautioned against interpreting the Democrats' electoral gains as evidence that the party was becoming an anti-war or anti-imperialist force.
He argued that both major parties remained closely tied to the same political establishment and that expectations of a fundamental shift in Washington's foreign policy were misplaced. Although some changes were emerging within the Democratic Party, he said, neither its congressional representatives nor its senators have demonstrated a consistent commitment to opposing imperialism or pursuing better relations with Iran.
Marandi also warned against overstating the significance of newly elected Democratic figures, arguing that their presence alone would not transform the party's political direction. The possible election of Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer to lead the House and Senate, respectively, would further limit expectations of a major departure from established Democratic positions.
"I have no great expectations about the Democratic Party suddenly becoming a force for good. That's not going to happen," the Iranian professor stated.
He pointed to the party's record during the genocide in Gaza and the war in Lebanon, as well as its role in US aggressions since September 11, arguing that its history offered little reason to expect a sudden transformation.
Nevertheless, the electoral outcome carried considerable significance because of the message sent by American voters.
Marandi said many had voted against Trump to express opposition to the war, the genocide, and the Israeli entity, rather than out of support for the Democratic Party itself. He stressed that this public sentiment represented a significant political force that both Republicans and Democrats would have difficulty ignoring.
The pressure could push Democrats toward certain changes, he said, although the party's political foundations would continue to constrain its response. If it failed to address public opposition to the war, Marandi warned, ordinary Americans could increasingly see the political system as offering no meaningful alternative, potentially paving the way for instability and the emergence of a third political force.
"They're two factions of the same political establishment. But the difference is that the people have made their voices heard, and if the Democratic Party does not deliver at all, then that means US politics is a dead end for ordinary people because the Republican Party is a dead end, and if the Democratic Party is a dead end, that means people will have nowhere to go, and that could lead to unrest, instability, and a rise of a third force, whatever that may be."
He also argued that the Israeli regime had suffered considerable reputational damage over the past three years, particularly in the United States, where public opposition to its policies had become increasingly consequential.
"With regard to the Israeli regime, there's no difference between the opposition and Netanyahu. They're both genocidal, and I think the people of Lebanon know quite well who the opposition is and what sort of genocidal maniacs are in the opposition," the Tehran University professor said.
The electoral developments, he said, were therefore damaging for the Israeli occupation, as well as for Trump, whose political difficulties extended beyond the US midterm elections to developments in occupied Palestine, Brazil, and Serbia.
"What has happened in the United States is not good for the Israeli regime, and what has happened in occupied Palestine is not good for Trump, alongside the fact that he's had a series of losses. I mean, the midterm elections were catastrophic. The election in occupied Palestine was bad. The election in Brazil was bad. And in Serbia, things did not go well for Trump either. So he's been losing constantly over the past couple of weeks."
Read more: US midterms, Lula's victory expose limits of far right in Americas
Marandi further stressed that Iran would not accept an indefinite situation of neither war nor peace, reiterating that Tehran had made it clear that it would determine when a renewed confrontation ended.
"If the United States starts another round of violence, that Iran will be – that decides when it ends. And that obviously means that Iran is going to continue striking until it achieves certain objectives," he said.
He argued that Tehran would use the existing circumstances to intensify pressure on Washington, including through the Strait of Hormuz, until the United States accepted its demands. Should Washington escalate militarily, Marandi said, Iran would respond forcefully and persistently.
Addressing Iran's diplomatic engagement, he also clarified that a visit by General Mohsen Rezaei to Russia was primarily concerned with bilateral relations rather than negotiations between Tehran and Washington.
The discussions focused on bilateral matters and projects aimed at strengthening political and economic cooperation between the two countries, he explained.
Meanwhile, Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi would continue pursuing diplomatic avenues, Marandi said, stressing that diplomacy remained part of his responsibilities and that Tehran would pursue a solution if one became possible.
However, he saw little indication that Washington was moving toward an agreement. Trump's choice of senior personnel, he argued, reinforced the expectation that the administration would maintain its current approach.
Marandi also anticipated that pressure from the new Congress would complicate Trump's position, particularly given public opposition to the war. Yet he cautioned that the coming months could bring significant developments, making it unwise to assume that Washington would change course without further confrontation.
Meanwhile, American journalist and human rights activist Jennifer Loewenstein warned that Trump's political difficulties could make him more inclined to escalate the confrontation with Iran rather than accept a diplomatic settlement, arguing that his personal and political calculations would continue to shape Washington's decisions despite mounting domestic opposition to the war.
On The Grand Standoff, Loewenstein said the divisions within the Republican establishment were likely to deepen following the Democrats' electoral gains. She also questioned the significance of Republican opposition to the war, arguing that some figures were primarily concerned with positioning themselves for future political ambitions.
Loewenstein pointed to the possibility that a Republican figure challenging Trump's approach could be seeking to establish a record of opposition ahead of the presidential campaign in 2028, seemingly referring to Vice President JD Vance, who has increasingly voiced opposition to the aggression.
"I really see it as a very self-serving act to, as I said, to put it on record that he opposed the war, I don't think that it shows much else other than how deeply divided the present Republican establishment is," she said.
She added that the electoral outcome had strengthened perceptions that the Trump era was approaching its end, although she cautioned that such a political shift would not necessarily translate into immediate changes in US policy.
Like Marandi, Loewenstein argued that the existing stalemate between Washington and Tehran could not continue indefinitely. "Something is either, either there's going to be an agreement and Trump is going to accept the Iranian demands or there's going to be an escalation. That's what I expect," she said.
However, she warned that the political damage Trump had already inflicted domestically and internationally could make him more vindictive, potentially prompting him to escalate the war as a way of demonstrating that he remained in control.
Loewenstein said she was concerned that Trump might seek to send a message to the Democratic establishment by intensifying the confrontation with Iran, particularly after suffering significant electoral setbacks.
She argued that his decisions would depend partly on intelligence he received, while also pointing to the influence of figures within his administration who favor a more confrontational approach toward Tehran.
Although Trump might ultimately want to bring the war to an end, Loewenstein feared that he could first pursue escalation rather than accept Iran's demands.
"I would love to see him change and say to himself, gee, this is so unpopular. I think we just better put an end to it. But I don't see that in Trump's psychological makeup. I think he can be vindictive," she said.
She also expressed concern over the influence of Stephen Miller, whom she described as a major supporter of the Israeli regime and a figure whose political outlook could favor the implementation of Netanyahu's strategy toward Iran.
Turning to the implications of the new Congress, Loewenstein cautioned against assuming that Democratic control would automatically lead to an end to the war or a more peaceful US foreign policy.
She argued that the Democratic Party had historically played a central role in US military interventions and that its opposition to Trump's handling of the confrontation with Iran did not necessarily reflect a commitment to ending the war through a comprehensive diplomatic settlement.
Although Democratic lawmakers have criticized the way the war was initiated and conducted, Loewenstein said Congress could seek to restrict Trump's actions through funding decisions without necessarily embracing a broader agreement.
She also distinguished between the positions of progressive lawmakers and the wider Democratic establishment, noting that some newly elected representatives have explicitly opposed the war while many others remained centrist and supportive of traditional US foreign policy positions.
"The Democrats have not traditionally been a peaceful party," she said, adding that the party's record offered little reason to assume it would pursue a fundamentally different course.
Loewenstein further argued that opposition to the war during an election campaign should not be confused with a willingness to accept Iran's demands once political power was secured.
"I don't see that being, you know, let's lay down our arms and shake hands and embrace each other," she said, warning that Democrats could seek to pursue diplomacy while simultaneously maintaining a hardline posture toward Tehran.
She stressed that Congress generally lagged behind public opinion rather than leading it, pointing to the changing attitudes of Americans toward the Israeli regime as an example.
According to Loewenstein, growing public opposition had helped bring new political figures into Congress, including Abdul El-Sayed, but their election would not immediately transform the institution or its foreign policy positions.
She argued that the shift in public sentiment was more significant than the immediate composition of Congress, suggesting that the relationship between the US public and the Israeli regime could undergo substantial changes over the coming decade.
Loewenstein also warned against efforts to present Eisenkot as a more moderate or morally acceptable alternative to Netanyahu, arguing that such a portrayal could allow the Israeli regime to restore its international standing without fundamentally changing its policies.
She said political circles in the United States could attempt to distinguish between Netanyahu and his potential successor, portraying the former as an extremist departure from an otherwise acceptable Israeli political establishment.
However, Loewenstein rejected this distinction, arguing that Eisenkot represented continuity rather than a meaningful political shift. "I think we have to be on our guard against that because Eisenkot does not represent change in Israel. He represents a constituency, more than 90% of which is far right," she said.
She further pointed to his role in authoring the "Dahiya doctrine", which she said was designed to maximize civilian casualties, arguing that his military record and positions toward Lebanon offered little basis for expecting a less aggressive Israeli policy.
Loewenstein warned that presenting Eisenkot as a moderate alternative could encourage Americans who had become critical of the Israeli regime to resume supporting it without demanding substantive changes.
"That's a dangerous path forward. We have to see Eisenkot as a continuation of the insanity of the Netanyahu years. He's part of the same cloth," she said.
Furthermore, the US journalist pointed to Eisenkot's military background, particularly his role in the Northern Command and his criticism of Netanyahu for not bombing Beirut when Washington had opposed such an operation.
"With Eisenkot in power, we're not going to see anything better," she said, warning that the combination of Trump's determination to retain control and the political calculations surrounding the Israeli leadership could create conditions for further escalation in the coming months.
She added that the issue could become a significant fault line in the 2028 US presidential elections, particularly because the Democratic establishment remained broadly supportive of the Israeli entity despite growing opposition among the American public.
Returning to the confrontation with Tehran, Loewenstein argued that Trump has placed himself in an increasingly difficult position by pursuing a war he could neither easily sustain nor end on his own terms.
She said Iran has a significant opportunity to press its demands, particularly given the limitations of Washington's military and diplomatic options.
Loewenstein also warned that any further US escalation would be unlikely to produce a military victory, arguing that Washington lacked the ability to defeat Iran in a prolonged confrontation.
"I'm afraid he's stepped into a minefield with the Iran war forever to get its demands met. I can see why Iran would, you know, move ahead with its weapons construction and its belligerent talk, because if Trump is stupid enough to escalate, and I believe he is, he's not going to win. The United States is not going to win this war," she said.
She maintained that the current circumstances offered Tehran an opportunity to secure its demands, stressing that Washington had repeatedly demonstrated its inability to pursue effective diplomacy.
Loewenstein also questioned whether the arrival of a new Congress would make a meaningful difference while Trump's principal diplomatic representatives, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, remained in place.
She noted that neither had a diplomatic background, raising further doubts about Washington's ability to negotiate a settlement acceptable to Tehran.
In her assessment, any US policy that stopped short of accepting Iran's demands, ending the blockade, and withdrawing from the confrontation would only deepen the crisis.