[Salon] Fwd: Harici: "Reconcile, deny, seal: From Kenya to Cyprus, Britain's colonial torture formula." (11/08/26)





Reconcile, deny, seal: From Kenya to Cyprus, Britain's colonial torture formula


Thomas Karat08.11.2026 13:48 Author

Thomas Karat, behavior analyst

In January 2019, the British government announced that it would pay thirty-three Cypriots who stated that they were tortured under British supervision during the 1955-1959 uprising. In the official statement accompanying the money, there was a sentence that readers in Nairobi would immediately recognize: London reported that the compromise reached did not mean acceptance of responsibility in any way and would not set a precedent for future lawsuits against the government. The same government, five and a half years ago, when it announced compensation for Kenyans who were tortured during the Mau Mau State of Emergency, did not prejudice the denial of responsibility and declared that the payment would not set a precedent for other former colonies. Two different geographies, two separate peoples who survived torture and a single formula that is moved from one continent to another with almost no touching their words. A sentence that goes from hand to hand in this way is part of a deep-rooted method. This method, which has a history from the colonial fires of the 1950s to the laws that are still in force today, is now punctuating at an active British airbase in Cyprus.

The State of Cyprus began in 1955 that the Greek Cypriot organization EOKA, which aims to unite with Greece (Enosis), started an armed action process against the British administration, which London described as terrorism. Violence was not flowing in one direction. According to the data shared by a Turkish Cypriot media outlet, EOKA killed 371 British soldiers between 1955 and 1959; Turkish Cypriots were among its victims, the first of which was police sergeant Abdullah Alparslan, who was killed in Paphos in 1956. None of the events change the legal position of a prisoner. The prohibition of torturing people in custody protects every prisoner for whatever purpose it serves; in fact, the issue where the British administration made the most effort to hide it from the eyes was the treatment of prisoners. Although the allegations of abuse were circulating at that time, colonial authorities fended them off as EOKA propaganda. No British soldier or police were tried for torture during the uprising; only two officers from the Gordon Highlanders unit were brought to the military court and found guilty of intentional injury. The EOKA veterans association states that fourteen Greek Cypriots, two of whom were only seventeen years old, lost their lives in British interrogations. In 2022, new evidence of these deaths were released based on the testimonies of British veterans and Cypriot militants, autopsy and morgue records, and photographs in the Cyprus State Archive showing the shattered genitals; along with these documents, British forces, including intelligence services, were accused of carrying out an extrajudicial execution operation for the first time during the uprising. Among the thirty-three plaintiffs who reached a compromise in 2019, there was a woman who said that she was repeatedly raped by soldiers at the age of sixteen.

For half a century, it was suggested that documents that could test these testimonies were not officially available. The document in question came to light thanks to a lawsuit filed on another continent. During the trial in Kenya, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs had to admit that it held about 9,000 files belonging to thirty-seven former colonial administrations, which were thought to have long been destroyed, according to the first counts. These included the Cyprus document, in which the British police and officers personally wrote the brutal treatment of EOKA suspected fighters and civilians. When the documents made available by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in July 2012 revealed allegations of torture and ill-treatment during the State of Emergency, thirty-five Cypriots filed a lawsuit in July 2015. Cyprus Mail, which reported the newly accessed material, reported that the top-secret files revealed that both EOKA suspected militants and ordinary civilians were subjected to severe torture during the State of Emergency. The plaintiffs' attorney had to convince the government to allow him to see the secret documents, which meant going to Hanslope Park, the protected State Department facility in Buckinghamshire, where the colonial archive was kept. A Labor Party MP from Cyprus pointed out that the government would prefer the case to never come to light on an issue where torture is definitely present. When an agreement is reached, the Minister in Charge of European Affairs described the pre-independence period as a process to be regretted and pointed out the time that had passed as a justification for the allegations could no longer be judged fairly. The aforementioned time period also included the period of fifty years, when the government made the relevant files inaccessible. Even the agreement was not enough to open the archive completely. During a subsequent visit by the plaintiffs' lawyer to Cyprus, it was announced that thousands of additional secret documents would be disclosed, including allegations of torture during the State of Emergency, which meant that some of the records of the incident were still unopened, even years after London paid money to close the case. The speed of this document reaching the public is still determined by the ministry that hides it in the first place.

The disappearance of those files was planned to be sifted and touched as thinly and frequently as all other wheels of colonial administration. From 1961, Colonial Minister Iain Macleod instructed officials in all remaining territories to identify and sort out any documents that could leave the British government or officials in a difficult situation or that could be considered evidence of racial or religious prejudice. The applied criterion was dignity: A document, regardless of its military value, was thrown into the fire according to the damage that Britain could do in its name. The files suitable for transfer to the new local government were marked as legacy, and those to be destroyed or secretly sent to London were marked as watch. Instructions stipulated that successive governments were not even aware of the existence of such files; therefore, when a file was taken from a series, it was replaced with a fake one. This liquidation work was entrusted only to British officers of European origin. Papers were burned, ashes were crumbled or filled into heavy chests and buried in deep waters far from the shore. In Belize, the files were burned with the help of the Royal Navy and tinks of gasoline. In British Guiana, two secretaries fed documents to a barrel of oil in the garden of the Government House until the army reached the rescue. A three-person committee in Aden began incineration in 1966, exactly one year before Britain's withdrawal. In Malaya, five truckloads of documents were taken to the naval base with a single liquidation; this was such a conspicuous destruction that officers in Kenya were later warned not to repeat it. After each completion of destruction, a signed report was sent to London. The program was called Operation Legacy.

Kenya was finally where the chain of concealment was broken. Three elderly victims who survived the Mau Mau State of Emergency concentration camps and were beaten and sexually tortured under the supervision of Britain filed a lawsuit against the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. In his witness statement, one of them described a period when men were resented and women were raped before independence. The ministry resisted the case for three years, claiming that the responsibility for the actions in the colonial era passed to the independent Kenyan state in 1963; the Supreme Court rejected this thesis. The hidden archive was clarified more than ten years after the lawsuit was filed, during this trial. Historians, whom the government turned a blind eye to the fact that they pretended wrong rather than accepting what they had, were right in their insistent thesis that the records were stolen and hidden. This document was converted into the FCO 141 catalog series in the National Archive, covering about twenty thousand files from about forty former colonies. In his speech at the House of Commons on June 6, 2013, the Minister of Foreign Affairs stated that the government would pay 19.9 million pounds to 5,228 plaintiffs and deeply regret the mistreatment; the statement maintained the condition of denial of responsibility and not setting precedents, which Cyprus would also hear in 2019.

This formula performs a highly punctual legal function. A payment made without accepting responsibility does not give rise to any judgment against the state and no court can decide what the files show. A payment that is declared not to set a precedent forces each group of victims in all other former colonies to start from scratch against a defendant who holds the documents and manages the speed of their emergence. Cypriot plaintiffs learned from the Kenya case that a compromise is possible; in fact, their lawyers made it clear that the government's resistance in Cyprus was unfounded, as the Mau Mau case had already shown where such cases would lead. Despite this, the government repeated the whole process from start to finish: It resisted the demands, objected to access to the files, and ultimately reached a compromise without taking responsibility. In addition, while Kenya received a monument erected as a symbol of reconciliation in Nairobi, no similar gesture was presented to Cyprus. Each case is treated as an exception; this is exactly the result that the formula is designed to provide.

An incomplete archive leaves no neutral space behind. The side opens up space for shortcuts and these shortcuts work against the community with the weakest access to the documents. While the BBC reported the agreement in 2019, it described the Turkish Cypriots as bandits in its news; the broadcaster later apologized for this statement and issued the text. The State of Emergency years shaped the relations between societies on the island; a complete narrative filtered from the files, not from competing memories, serves both Turkish Cypriots and Greek Cypriots equally. The side that misses that narrative is the old colonial power that wrote the reports and decided which ones could be read even today.

Fire was a rough vehicle. The permanent tool is based on the law and still works. The Public Records Act stipulates that the document chosen for permanent preservation will be made available to the public within twenty years; this period was reduced to thirty years in 2010. The relevant paragraph of the same article allows ministries to keep records if it is necessary for administrative purposes or if it is necessary to be detained for any other special reason; the law, in its broadest interpretation, allows a total detention authority covering an entire class of files, provided that it is reviewed every decade. In 2013, the Department of Foreign Affairs had been violating the Law for years for years, an additional material, which consists of approximately 1.2 million files, which it calls private collections, and covers about twenty-four kilometers of space on the shelves. The Justice Minister responded to this violation by signing a wholesale permit and turned the irregularity into a legal detention; a group of historians considered going to justice under both the Public Records Act and the Freedom of Information Act. Hong Kong's colonial files are still kept on key with a decision valid until 2047. In 2015, the authority to approve the detention was transferred to a Minister from the House of Lords' Chancelly, and the authorization document was removed from being the Chancellor's Certificate and the full Detention Document. The role of the chancellor provided somewhat independent control over the public record system, with this amendment, the decision was left to the direct initiative of the ministries that held the records and had their own grounds to keep them closed. Between 2017 and 2019, the British army's headquarters in Kenya destroyed most of the physical files created before 2015, while it had been a few years since the ministers expressed their regret before Parliament for such casualties.

Destruction and storage determine what will be passed into the archive. A third tool manages what will reach the courtroom. English law has adopted the principle that justice must be clearly seen since Lord Hewart's 1924 decision; this principle has long been considered part of the rule of law. The Law of Justice and Security of 2013 has included closed evidence procedures in ordinary civil proceedings for the first time. When a lawsuit is filed against the government for the actions of its own institutions, it can now rely on evidence that the plaintiff and the plaintiff's lawyer never see. A private lawyer who has passed the security investigation examines the material for them, then is prohibited from negotiating it with the person whose interests he defends. The private lawyers themselves informed the Parliament that these procedures were unfair by nature and were contrary to the tradition of customary law. The Law Society warned that the law undermined the principle of equality of weapons, which is the basis of a fair trial. A senior high judge, who has just retired, described the regulation as such a radical deviation from open justice that he argued that no matter how much assurances there is any should be brought into effect against its use; the government's own equality and human rights watch board was of the opinion that the bill was incompatible with European human rights norms. Parliament turned a deaf ear to all these objections and passed the law. In 2014, prosecutors applied for a terrorist case in which the identities of the defendants were kept secret to be heard behind completely closed doors. The Court of Appeal rejected a complete motting, ruling that criminal proceedings should be public and that the defendants should be clearly stated, and noted its deep concern about this attempt. The case was still closed in essence; a small group of journalists allowed to watch the hearings was required not to write down almost any of what they heard and to hand over their notebooks to the court.

This effort, which was carried out from two separate branches, was set up simultaneously. The Justice and Security Act received royal approval on April 25, 2013. Six weeks later, on June 6, the same government expressed its sorrow in the House of Commons over the evidence of colonial torture, which it had hidden for fifty years and only delivered under the coercion of a court. With an apology for a past cover-up, the legal mechanism of future cover-ups came from the hands of the same government in a single legislative period. The Cyprus reconciliation, which was reached six years later, repeated the words of that apology to the letter while the mechanism in question was in place.

This saik can be read between the lines of the archive itself. A state that presents itself as the guardian of the rule of law in the world and is at the table as one of the guarantors of independent Cyprus, takes most of its legitimacy from the claim that its own actions can be based on all kinds of control. Documented torture, which is examined in the open court, refutes this claim and reveals the perpetrators name by name. Although the vehicles differ according to the stages they intervene, the benefit they protect is the same: Destruction prevents the evidence from reaching the court. Detention hides the surviving files from historians for decades; closed procedures hide the evidence from the public even after it comes before the judge. The Court of Appeal revealed the essence of the issue in its 2014 decision; It defined open justice as an indispensable attribute of the rule of law, the assurance that the state's savings in its own courts can be controlled by the people on whose behalf it acts. Each tool transferred here is a way to eliminate this control. The cost of this practice, which has been maintained for half a century, shows the magnitude of the value assigned to the protected benefit. Because no government keeps a secret archive for fifty years in order to protect the material it deems harmless, does not legalize detention when it is exposed, and does not re-arrange the law of its own civil proceedings.

The British state maintains much more than the archives in Cyprus. Under the 1960 Founding Treaty, the island gained independence, except for two regions in Agrotur and Dikelia, which remained under British sovereignty; with the Treaty of Guarantee accompanying the text, Turkey, Greece and the United Kingdom committed to guarantee the independence, territorial integrity and security of the Republic of Cyprus. Shadow R1 type surveillance aircraft belonging to the Royal Air Force, which took off from Ağrotur, have performed hundreds of missions in and around the skies of Gaza since December 2023; According to the review carried out by the organization Action on Armed Violence for Declassified UK, this number was at least 518, the institution later updated this data to 606. The Ministry of Defense argued that the flights only served to locate the hostages and refused to explain whether the live surveillance recordings were shared with Israel. Upon the application for information, the ministry confirmed that it was in its possession of footage of Gaza from the flight on April 1, 2024, the day when seven international aid workers, three of whom were British army veterans, were killed in the Israeli attacks; however, it avoided publishing these records for national security reasons.

The island, where British officials kept colonial files out of sight at the time, today hosts a British base where the records of a current war are strapped on familiar reasons. This reflex, which is traced through Kenya and Cyprus, is not reserved for a single state. The second part of this series follows the reflex in question to Israel: to Israel, which was recorded by Israeli soldiers themselves, to a scale where his army's actions in Gaza and the West Bank could not be taken, and which was often recorded by Israeli soldiers themselves, and whose officials have since tried to delete these records from the media where they were first published. Britain's method was based on the assumption that evidence could be stored in a single place and managed for decades. In an age where evidence is everywhere at the same time, the second chapter puts the question of what that method will become.



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.