[Salon] Seventy Years Ago, Ben-Gurion Warned of What Ruling Gaza Could Cost Israel




Seventy Years Ago, Ben-Gurion Warned of What Ruling Gaza Could Cost Israel

Newly released transcripts from the 1956 Sinai Campaign show Israel's first prime minister warning that continued rule over Gaza could bring terrorism, international isolation, an arms embargo and profound moral damage

Ofer Aderet
Ofer Aderet
 • November 09 2026
שבעים שנה למלחמת סיני
Ben-Gurion at the Gaza Strip border, March 1957, amid fears of international isolation. Credit: Vered Avraham

Israel's first prime minister, David Ben-Gurion, warned 70 years ago about the military, diplomatic and moral ramifications of Israeli rule over the Gaza Strip.

But he admitted that there was no good solution, since "the Gaza Strip will be a problem for any government, no matter what government it has."

His statements appear in transcripts made public on Sunday to mark the 70th anniversary of the Sinai Campaign in November 1956. During that war, Israel captured Gaza and the Sinai Peninsula for the first time, but withdrew four months later. 

Prime Minister and Defense Minister David Ben-Gurion during a visit to Sinai. The difficult questions surrounding the future of the Gaza Strip remained unresolved.
Prime Minister and Defense Minister David Ben-Gurion during a visit to Sinai. The difficult questions surrounding the future of the Gaza Strip remained unresolved. Credit: Boris Carmi / IDF and Defense Ministry Archives.

The documents – a few of which have been published before in books, articles or other archives – now appear in the IDF and Defense Establishment Archives, which provides comprehensive textual and visual documentation of the war's military and diplomatic aspects.

Seventy years later, the same questions about Gaza's fate persist, as evident from a transcript of a conference for senior officers in April 1957. Ben-Gurion, the main speaker, discussed the strategic, security and diplomatic conditions behind Israel's withdrawal from the captured territory, but also the moral argument against ruling over another people.

"This might have destroyed us, not militarily, but morally," he said. "In my view, the moral aspect confers our entire existence. If we lose our moral right to exist, in our own eyes and in the world's eyes, Israel can't exist." 

Ben-Gurion warns of an arms embargo on Israel.
Ben-Gurion warns of an arms embargo on Israel. Credit: Vered Avraham / IDF and Defense Ministry Archives

He also warned of harsh international sanctions against Israel. "We can defeat the Egyptian, Jordanian and Syrian armies ... but we can't give orders to the world," he said.

Ben-Gurion explained the withdrawal in part due to his fear of terrorist attacks from Gazans and the world's response should Israel strike back. "It was clear that staying in Gaza when the world was ostracizing us, if there were terror and we had to suppress it ... that terror would have destroyed us."

He also discussed world sympathy for the Gazans. "Those 300,000 residents know the entire Arab world stands with them against us, and behind the Arab world is the declared political sympathy of the entire world ... One can imagine what would have been done in that Gaza, where the population is exclusively Arab, and not just Arab, but embittered people whose fields and homes, as they see it, were taken from them, and foreigners, as they see us, are living there ... We couldn't have withstood this. We couldn't have withstood this in a place with so many refugees." 

IDF Chief of Staff Moshe Dayan during the evacuation of El-Arish in 1957. Ben-Gurion had made clear that he had never intended to enter the Gaza Strip in the first place.
IDF Chief of Staff Moshe Dayan during the evacuation of El-Arish in 1957. Ben-Gurion had made clear that he had never intended to enter the Gaza Strip in the first place. Credit: IDF and Defense Ministry Archives

Ben-Gurion said that even when he launched the war, he never intended to stay in Gaza. He was aware of the danger of terror attacks from Gaza against communities in southern Israel, he continued, "But there are bigger considerations. Consequently, from the first moment, I vehemently opposed those who demanded that we annex Gaza. That's not what Israel is lacking – another 300,000 Arabs ... and tomorrow UNRWA will tell us, 'You provide for the refugees, and not just the refugees.'"

He also stressed the risks of international isolation and the possibility that Israel wouldn't be able to obtain weapons from abroad for the next war. 

In the Sinai Campaign, Israel fought together with Britain and France against Egypt. However, he warned, "We have no basis for assuming that in the [next] war, we'll have forces helping us from outside ... and if we're ostracized by the world, there's a real risk, if not a certain one ... that when the time comes that the Arab states think they have the power to destroy us, about whether we'll be able to obtain weapons. 

IDF Chief of Staff Moshe Dayan in Sinai.
IDF Chief of Staff Moshe Dayan in Sinai. Credit: Vered Avraham / IDF and Defense Ministry Archives

"I don't know how we would fight then," he continued. "Maybe we'd win anyway, even if they have planes and bombers that are much better than ours. But I don't know what the cost would be, and we can't pay such a price." For instance, he said, "We don't have so many Tel Aviv residents; they could be bombed and destroyed in a day. I would see this as knowingly committing suicide."

Yet another concern, he said, is the situation of overseas Jewry. Israeli Jews, he stressed, are only "a small part of our people. The vast majority of the Jewish people is scattered throughout the world ... If Israel were ostracized by the entire world, I don't know what situation the Jews of America, Argentina, the Scandinavian countries, Belgium and Holland would be in." 

"In everything we do in Israel, we cannot fail to take into account not only the help [Israel gets] from these Jews – and Jews overseas don't exist solely to help us; we also have to take their position, their needs, what situation they are in into account." 

Finally, he warned that any future war might well be far more deadly for Israeli civilians than the Sinai Campaign, in which the casualties were all soldiers. "It won't be like that in the next war," he said. "Tel Aviv will be bombed, Haifa will be bombed and people will be killed. Not soldiers. Women, children."

At that conference, he also quoted from his own remarks during the cabinet meeting on October 28, 1956, just before the Sinai Campaign began. Those remarks, which have been published previously, included the following statement about Gaza: "If I believed in miracles, I would want it swallowed by the sea." But as his speech made clear, absent such a miracle, Israel would have to deal with Gaza as it is.

Haaretz Podcast | 'A new elite': Behind the U.S. money launching Israel's far-right to power


This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.