Apparently, when two Arabs – who also happen to think – sit down for a conversation on a podcast, it constitutes a 'threat' to national security to the extent that the Shin Bet must get involved
On the eve of the Knesset election in October, we published a new episode of the "Al-Midan" podcast on the Arab48 website, which I edit. In the episode, my colleague Abed Abu Shehadeh interviews former Balad lawmaker Azmi Bishara, who now lives in Qatar. The podcast received tens of thousands of listens and views.
Nine days later, early last Wednesday morning, 15 armed and masked men raided Abu Shehadeh's home and arrested him in front of his partner and young children. A judge granted the state's request to extend his detention by five days. He was only released on Sunday.
A journalistic interview turned into a serious security offense. Abu Shehadeh was detained by the Shin Bet security service on suspicion of contact with a foreign agent and was interrogated at its detention facility. This happened even though Abu Shehadeh is a well-known journalist in his community, while his interviewee is an intellectual and researcher who heads one of the most productive and important research institutes in the entire region.
"Al-Midan" is a weekly podcast that's been running for five years. Its guests include academics, social and political activists, commentators and experts from a wide range of fields. More than 250 episodes have been published to date, making it a prominent and popular platform. Abu Shehadeh is the editor of our podcast department and also produces podcasts for other clients. He is a prolific writer, and dozens of his articles in English, Arabic and Hebrew are available online.
Abu Shehadeh's and Bishara's "crime" is that they are Arabs. Apparently, when two Arabs – who also happen to think – sit down for a conversation on a podcast, it constitutes a "threat" to national security to the extent that the Shin Bet must get involved.
This is the reality in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's and Shin Bet chief David Zini's Israel: an Arab journalist persecuted and imprisoned in a special nighttime operation over a candid interview that garnered tens of thousands of views online.
The conversation between Abu Shehadeh and Bishara was no clandestine meeting; it was an encounter between a well-known journalist and a prominent intellectual. Quite a few Israeli journalists have approached Bishara for interviews; some have even proposed interviews in which questions would be agreed upon in advance.
Abu Shehadeh, who speaks fluent English, visited Doha at the invitation of Al Jazeera English to serve as a political commentator during Israel's election campaign. Who better to help Al Jazeera's viewers make sense of the Israeli election than a young Arab-Palestinian citizen of Israel, a resident of Tel Aviv-Jaffa, with a master's degree in political science?
While in Doha, without any prior arrangements, Abu Shehadeh interviewed Bishara, who founded Balad and who was suspected of aiding Hezbollah during the Second Lebanon War, subsequently fleeing Israel. Their conversation lasted about an hour and focused on the Israeli election and the implications of its outcome for Arab citizens of Israel and the region as a whole.
The Shin Bet and the police were seeking to prevent Abu Shehadeh from practicing his profession as a journalist and media commentator, despite the fact that journalism is his occupation and primary source of income. The reason is that questioning a journalist requires the approval of the State Prosecutor's Office – an approval that in this case was not obtained. To circumvent the rules, the police representative described Abu Shehadeh at the detention hearing as a "political adviser" rather than a political commentator.
If the government cannot bend the law, the Shin Bet, under Zini's leadership, will find a way around it, with one goal: to delegitimize the Arab voters who prevented Netanyahu from securing the Knesset majority he needed. The way to do this is to cast doubt on the integrity of Arab voters' intentions, as though they have no independent existence, no consciousness or political considerations of their own, and are motivated solely by foreign money.
This is a conspiracy theory straight out of Netanyahu-aligned Channel 14 and its stable of commentators. The aim isn't to incriminate Abu Shehadeh or Bishara, but to cling to power by any means necessary.
An Arab journalist and podcaster was held for five days in a Shin Bet detention facility over a one-hour interview. He could have been summoned for questioning or issued a warning. But the regime chose a nighttime raid to send a message of intimidation, invoking the felony of "contact with a foreign agent" – one of the most serious offenses on the books.
But there was no "contact" and no "foreign agent." We're talking about a frank interview published online, a conversation between a journalist and a democratic Arab intellectual, between two people who belong to this land.
Rami Mansour is the editor of the Arab48 website.