[Salon] A no-deal exit from the Iran war




A deal with Tehran is welcome but not needed, will Hegseth survive, a lame-duck Trump, and more
A deal with Tehran is welcome but not needed, what happens if Trump fires Hegseth, a lame-duck Trump, and more

A no-deal exit also serves U.S. interests

An F/A-18 Super Hornet takes off from the flight deck aboard Nimitz-class aircraft carrier USS George Washington in the Middle East. Photo: U.S. Navy
  • In a recent interview, President Trump again claimed the Iran war has been "won," that Tehran can no longer make a nuclear weapon and is desperate for a deal, and that the Strait of Hormuz is open. Not true. And as Ross Douthat noted, more ships are passing through the strait only by being "babysat" by the U.S. Navy (at great cost), and oil prices remain high.
     
  • A deal that ends the conflict would be welcome. If Vice President Vance's recent diplomatic efforts are any indication, this would attempt to impose limits on its nuclear program and tolls on shipping in the strait in exchange for sanctions relief for Iran and an end to U.S. bombing. But a deal isn't necessary for America—nor is it worth prolonging the war.
     
  • Iranian tolls on shipping in the strait aren't optimal. They are an unfortunate consequence of this war, which should have never happened. But these fees are relatively low-cost compared to the much higher cost of disrupted traffic to the global market, and diffuse compared to U.S. military escorts and blockade operations that concentrate costs for American taxpayers and are dangerous to its troops.
     
  • A no-deal exit would be fine for U.S. interests, even if humiliating for President Trump. But the greater political risk comes from prolonging a war the American people strongly rejected last Tuesday.
     
  • The best course of action for U.S. interests, American taxpayers, and the Trump administration is to resolve this war as quickly as possible with or without good-enough diplomacy.
INTERVIEW

'This strategy of no strategy'

President Trump may fire Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, as some commentators have suggested, said Rosemary Kelanic, DEFP Middle East program director, in an interview with Forbes. But, she argued, "it won't make much of a difference if he fires Hengseth and continues on this strategy of no strategy—of just sort of intermittently bombing Iran and hoping that a settlement is reached. That hasn't worked for months now."
 
WATCH THE FULL INTERVIEW
QUOTED

"[T]he strategic logic of what you hope to achieve through an escalation of strikes against Iran is no different today than it was a week ago or a month ago."

– Brian Haggerty, DEFP non-resident fellow, in "After midterm loss, Trump is left to weigh his next move in Iran war that contributed to GOP debacle" [AP / Aamer Madhani et al.]

SOBER ANALYSIS

The end of primacy without pain


[Carnegie Endowment / Stephen Wertheim]
  • "In the view of much of the national-security community, a more competitive international arena requires more from the United States in order to uphold all the commitments it has made. America's politics, meanwhile, offers the world no more, amounting to less for increasingly demanding tasks."
     
  • "American power rests not only on the nation's resources but also on the will of its people and political system to direct them abroad. In a democratic society, the popular will deserves respect and warrants serious analysis. It is not immutable, nor is it infinitely malleable."
     
  • "For some time now, America's uniquely extensive foreign-policy objectives have grown more demanding while Americans themselves have demanded greater focus on their own affairs. U.S. global power has escaped its domestic moorings—less because of Trump and right-wing populism than because the post-unipolar world is straining America's commitments and its long-standing political consensus to keep foreign policy cheap."
Read the full analysis.
TRENDING

Three places where Trump's post-election foreign policy could ramp up

Democrats plan to choke off Iran war—with some GOP help

The next Congress shouldn't let Iran become a 'background war'

Poll: Trump, Hegseth underwater with active military, veterans

Veteran homelessness on decline for most of the U.S.
 

READ THE LATEST FROM DEFP EXPERTS


This email was sent to cwfresidence@gmail.com. Manage your email preferences, or
unsubscribe to stop receiving emails from Defense Priorities.

Defense Priorities Foundation is a non-profit organization formed under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. Donations are unlimited and deductible for Federal Income Tax purposes.
 
DONATE

Copyright © 2026 Defense Priorities 2311 Wilson Blvd Fl 3 Arlington, VA 22201 USA
defensepriorities.org


This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.