[Salon] Some Israeli Doctors Refuse to Stay Silent About the Scabies Epidemic in Israeli Prisons . . . becoming a torture device for thousands of Palestinian detainees. "




11/10/26

Some Israeli Doctors Refuse to Stay Silent About the Scabies Epidemic in Israeli Prisons 

A view of Ofer Prison from the outside.
A view of Ofer Prison from the outside. Credit: Itay Cohen

Not all Israeli healthcare professionals are complacent about the ease with which the scabies epidemic spread in Israel's prisons, becoming a torture device for thousands of Palestinian detainees. 

On September 1, 627 medical, mental health and social work professionals sent a letter to the chief medical officer of the Israel Prison Service, signing their full names. The letter, marked by its restrained tone is questioning the prison medical teams' ability to fulfill their professional duties.

One part of the letter refers to teenager Mohammed Sliman, who was arrested by soldiers at his home in February and contracted scabies in Ofer Prison in May. As a result, he was hospitalized at Jerusalem's Shaare Zedek Medical Center in July and underwent two heart surgeries and a leg amputation in August.

Chen Maanit and Matan Golan were the first to report on the calamity that befell him. They reported that during a court hearing on a petition by Physicians for Human Rights Israel against the prohibition on his family visiting him, the Israel Prison Service announced his release from detention.

However, it was the August 29 article by Gideon Levy and Alex Levac on the teen's condition that prompted the 627 professionals to contact Brig. Gen. Liav Goldstein, the Prison Service's chief medical officer.

"As a doctor," they wrote, "you know that scabies is a parasitic skin disease caused by the scabies mite, which burrows tunnels in the outer layer of the skin and lays eggs in them. It develops in humans under poor hygiene conditions and in crowded situations. In its early stages, it is a very bothersome disease, but simple to diagnose and treat with a topical ointment or oral medication. Without diagnosis and treatment, the itching and wounds can lead to secondary bacterial infection, and from there to cellulitis, sepsis, endocarditis, septic emboli and risk of death."

After summarizing the teenager's condition, the letter writers asked, "How did a disease, simple and readily treatable, deteriorate to the point of a life-threatening condition and irreversible disability in a young, healthy teenager?" They asked Dr. Goldstein to order not only an investigation into this specific case, but also to ensure detainees' access to a doctor and a medical examination, to establish procedures to prevent similar cases, to conduct periodic monitoring and to report on unanswered requests. 

They also requested an examination of the direct responsibility of the facility's doctors for the hygiene and nutrition conditions of the detainees and prisoners: It is known, they wrote, that scabies is a disease that can be prevented with clean bedding and clothing, access to showers and laundry and adequate nutrition. They did not mention this, so I will reiterate something else that is known: Despite its repeated denials, the Israel Prison Service goes above and beyond to ensure that these basic conditions are not met in Palestinian detention facilities.

Dr. Goldstein replied two weeks later: There is no basis for allegations of inadequate treatment, no fault was found in the conduct of the medical personnel, and in the absence of a waiver of confidentiality, he cannot provide further details. "The detainee was treated according to his medical condition, and if the petitioners have medical documentation contradicting this, it should be submitted immediately; in its absence, there is no basis for continuing to spread these accusations," he wrote. He did not address the general requests in the letter.

The Israel Prison Service spokesperson didn't answer my question as to why Goldstein did not address the fundamental questions in the letter, and wrote – as in all its responses to Haaretz – that everything is in order "and in accordance with Health Ministry guidelines and under the review and supervision of many official inspectors, including judges."

The spokesperson's response on October 1 further stated that "any detainee requiring medical treatment is examined and treated according to their condition and professional medical discretion. Concurrently, sanitation, cleaning and environmental treatment activities are carried out in the detention facilities as needed. Living conditions in the detention facilities, including the supply of clothing, bedding and hygiene products, are regulated in accordance with the procedures and instructions applicable to the Israel Prison Service."

Copies of the letter signed by the 627 medical professionals were also sent to Hatem Azzam, deputy commissioner of prisons, Vadim Goldstein, commander of Ofer Prison, Moshe Bar Siman Tov, the Health Ministry director general who has since stepped down from the position, Dr. Hagar Mizrahi, head of the Health Division at the Health Ministry, Prof. Arie Ben Yehuda, commissioner for public complaints regarding medical professions at the Health Ministry, Prof. Zion Hagay, chairman of the Israel Medical Association, Dr. Yosef Walfish, chairman of the Israel Medical Association's Ethics Bureau, and Haim Katz, the health minister.

The Health Ministry informed psychologist Arnona Zehavi, one of the letter's initiators, that they had "opened an inquiry into the matter with the relevant parties," and the Ethics Bureau stated that it had contacted the Israel Prison Service. Since the second half of September, Zehavi has not received any updates.

Zehavi told Haaretz that "the Israel Prison Service relies on medical confidentiality in its response. Confidentiality is the patient's right; it is meant to protect them. It should not become a shield for the system against questions.

"There is no need to disclose a diagnosis, test result or personal medical detail to explain how a minor in detention gets to see a doctor, how a medical complaint is documented, what happens when it goes unanswered, how deterioration is identified, and what control mechanisms are in place when an infectious disease spreads within a detention facility. We understand that we have received Brig. Gen. Liav Goldstein's response. We are still awaiting Dr. Liav Goldstein's professional and ethical response."



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.