Months before winning Texas' 30th Congressional District, progressive Dallas pastor Frederick Douglass Haynes III kicked off his campaign by declaring that Jesus Christ opposed genocide.
"If it's in Gaza, he's against it," Haynes said in January. "If it's in Haiti, he's against it. If it's in Congo, the Sudan, my savior is against genocide."
Haynes, the pastor for Friendship-West Baptist Church in Dallas, was not the only newly-elected Democrat to invoke his faith in criticizing Israel's war in Gaza on the campaign trail. Fellow Texas Democrat James Talarico, a state representative and Presbyterian seminarian who won his bid for Senate against Ken Paxton, framed the suffering in Gaza as a call from God in an MSNBC interview early in his campaign.
"There's a theologian who said, I screamed at God for the starving children until I realized the starving children was God screaming at me," Talarico said. "And God is screaming at all of us in Gaza as we speak."
In Kansas, Adam Hamilton, a United Methodist megachurch pastor who became the state's first Democratic senator in 94 years last week, told Politico last month that "what Israel has done in destroying Gaza is both irresponsible and unjust."
Now, as the three men head to Congress, they join a new cohort of Democrats whose faith-forward politics notched victories in Republican strongholds across the country – while offering a progressive Christian counterpoint to the evangelical support for Israel that has long dominated the religious debate over the U.S.-Israel relationship.
But while Haynes, Hamilton and Talarico leaned heavily on their Christian faith throughout their campaigns, Matthew Taylor, a visiting scholar at the Center on Faith and Justice at Georgetown University and author of the 2026 book "Defying Tyrants," warned against defining them as a united cohort of the "religious left."
"I think of the three of them as occupying different positions on a center-left continuum," Taylor said. "It's hard to conflate the three of them, other than to say they are not right."
Indeed, the three men come from vastly different denominational backgrounds, with large implications for the ways they approach the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Talarico, who supports a two-state solution, called for halting offensive weapons sales to Israel while continuing to support defensive systems such as Iron Dome. Hamilton, the senior pastor of the United Methodist Church of the Resurrection, called for ending offensive aid to Israel and has objected to describing its war in Gaza as "genocide."
Haynes, meanwhile, a pastor aligned with the historically Black National Baptist Convention, used his sermon on Oct. 8, 2023 to accuse Israel of "apartheid."
In a February statement accepting his endorsement from A New Policy PAC, he linked U.S. support for war in Gaza to racism at home. "I believe that our struggles are connected," Haynes said. "The racism we see in local zoning policies here at home and white supremacy in funding of a genocide in Palestine are cut from the same cloth."
The election also sent other Democratic Christian clergy to Congress, including Democrat LaKesha Womack, an ordained deacon in the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, who ousted a Republican incumbent in a House race in North Carolina, and has voiced support for conditioning U.S. aid to Israel.
"With the white Christian nationalists almost taking over the narrative of what it means to be a Christian, I think there are a lot of people of faith in this country who wanted to reclaim that narrative," Womack told the Associated Press.
In Iowa, Lindsay James, a Presbyterian chaplain, and Sarah Trone Garriott, a pastor in the mainline Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, both flipped House seats. They will join ordained Democrats already serving in Congress, including Georgia Sen. Raphael Warnock, a Baptist pastor, and Missouri Rep. Emanuel Cleaver, a United Methodist pastor.
Daniel Hummel, a historian of religion in the U.S., said the incoming cohort's explicitly religious framing distinguishes them from previous Democrat critics of Israel.
"The difference from this group of new politicians compared to older progressive critiques, is that they're going to be framed in an explicitly Christian or religious register," said Hummel, who is the director of the Lumen Center in Madison, Wisconsin, a Christian research institute. "Part of the point there is to try to claim back the biblical language from the evangelicals who frequently cite biblical passages for why they support Israel."
A split on the Christian right
Their arrival also comes as Israel's evangelical supporters have faced challenges within the Republican coalition. After Vice President JD Vance cited the war in Iran and the U.S. relationship with Israel in explaining Republicans' midterm losses, CUFI Action Fund, the political arm of Christians United for Israel, accused him of blaming Jews, and said politicians on both sides were using "Jewish people as a scapegoat and political steppingstone."
Christians United for Israel, which boasts a membership of over 10 million, had long been a "juggernaut" in Republican politics, Taylor said, but has been forced to reckon with the ascension of the "America First" faction on the right, including far-right Christian pundit Tucker Carlson and antisemitic Catholic influencer Nick Fuentes. "Christian Zionism is no longer the default position on the American Christian right," Taylor said.
For Christian leaders who have spent years pressing for changes to the U.S. policy toward Israel, the election felt like a turning point. Rev. Mae Elise Cannon, the executive director of Churches for Middle East Peace and herself an evangelical, said that Talarico and Hamilton could reach Christians who have been unsure how to engage on Israel and Palestine.
"When you look at somebody like Hamilton and when you look at Talarico, they're moderates within their own denominations, and so I think a lot of people are going to follow them," Cannon said.
Todd Deatherage, the co-founder of Telos, a Washington D.C.-based nonprofit that works primarily with American Christian leaders and communities on Israeli-Palestinian peacemaking, said he has already seen growing openness to Palestinian perspectives in recent years, particularly among younger Christians.
"The Christian voice that has been heard publicly for some years now has not sounded like this. It has not really centered the humanity of all in this kind of way, and has not defined itself as a politics of loving your neighbor," Deatherage said.
"But I think there is definitely a desire to reframe that by a lot of Christians, and I think that's part of why there was a lot of success amongst a number of these candidates," Deatherage said. "They were speaking in a voice that sounded more true to what Christianity is for many many Americans."
Preliminary exit polls showed that Democrats gained some ground amongst Christian voters, including Catholics and Protestants. Melissa Deckman, the CEO of the Public Religion Research Institute, said the candidates' religious messaging may have contributed to their appeal among voters already angry about political corruption, the war in Iran and the cost of living.
But Deckman also cautioned that it was too soon to tell if those shifts would last.
"Whether this represents an actual sea change in how white Christians vote, we'll have to see," Deckman said. "They've tended to vote in general with Republican candidates. Whether that changes in the future, it's kind of hard to tell at this point."
For Taylor, the incoming cohort of Christian lawmakers reflected a change in Christian sentiments on Israel that had already long been underway.
"The spectrum of Christian politicians more accurately reflects today the spectrum of actual Christian debate in the United States around Israel," Taylor said.