[Salon] Impeaching the President: Would It Be Productive, or Counterproductive?




11 out of 44 likely Republicans in the next Senate seems out of reach.
͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­

(Dobbs) Impeaching the President: Would It Be Productive, or Counterproductive?

11 out of 44 likely Republicans in the next Senate seems out of reach.

Nov 11
 




 

Now that Democrats are about to run Congress, there is talk about impeaching the president. Heaven knows, he deserves it. His list of high crimes and misdemeanors— one of the constitutional grounds for impeachment— would fill a yellow legal pad.

But to hear presumptive House speaker Hakeem Jeffries tell it, maybe the appetite’s not there. He said shortly after last week’s Democratic landslide, “I haven’t had a single member of the House Democratic Caucus talk to me about impeachment.” That doesn’t mean some aren’t thinking about it and some might do it, but he says his members have had more important things on their minds: “We’ve been relentlessly focused on affordability and on accountability.”

However, impeachment is accountability, and they already started on Trump’s lieutenants. Eight articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth were read yesterday on the floor of the House. For his incompetent, illusory, and without the approval of Congress, his illegal performance in the war with Iran, and for his extrajudicial killings of alleged narco-traffickers in the Pacific and the Caribbean, Hegseth was charged with violating the Constitution.

And although every Democrat who voted said yes to these articles of impeachment, they came not from a Democrat but from a Republican congressman, Thomas Massie. He just doesn’t think the leaders of the Executive Branch are good Republicans. But his short crusade failed. Every Republican except Massie voted to table the impeachment resolution, which killed it. Hegseth escaped the ultimate accountability. There is nothing though to prevent the Democrats from reintroducing the articles, once they are in the majority.

Because if accountability is the goal, there is no stronger tool than impeachment. Although they might be chastened by the outcome on Hegseth, Democrats also talk of impeaching Health and Human Services Secretary Bobby Kennedy Jr., and Attorney General Todd Blanche. However, trying to impeach any or all of them is a compromise. It’s a way to drive accountability without taking it clear up to the White House where, some Democrats fear, it would just create chaos, and they would open themselves to the charge that this is all they care about because they have no positive plans of their own.

According to Time Magazine, even Representative Jamie Raskin, who led the legal team against Donald Trump in his first impeachment, “draws a distinction between establishing grounds for impeachment and deciding whether another trial would be the best use of Congress’s time and political capital.” Now-Senator Adam Schiff, who led Trump’s impeachment prosecution in the Senate, says, “There’s no question he’s been engaging in conduct that is very likely impeachable. The question is, is it viable?” But Adam Smith, who will chair the House Armed Service Committee next year, told Time, “Trump has become beyond dangerous. He is just completely out of control in what he says and how he is governing. I think we have to try, even if it doesn’t succeed.”

It’s a tough call because it is about accountability. The Constitution not only says federal officers can be removed “for treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors,” it says they “shall be removed.”

Based on his performance as president, Donald Trump arguably is guilty of all three. So how can they not impeach him? If they don’t, then they are ignoring the time-tested principle in this nation that no man is above the law. That’s where Trump wants to be: above the law. But he’s not. If he has committed treason, bribery, or high crimes and misdemeanors, then that should not be ignored. But is it worth the kind of mayhem it might cause? Is it worth another January 6th?

This guy deserves to be run out of town on a rail. He is unfit to be the commander-in-chief of our armed forces, he is unfit to run the American economy, and he is morally unfit to be the leader of the free world. The fact that at times he is palpably unstable and unhinged only reinforces that.

So how likely is it that if Donald Trump is brought up next year for impeachment, he would escape conviction as he has twice before? In the House, the threshold to impeach is a simple majority: 218 votes. Right now it looks like there might be up to estimated 259 or 260 Democrats in the next session. So even if a couple of dozen think it’s bad idea, it’s still probably a done deal.

But in the Senate, not so much. There could be as many as 56 Democratic senators in the next session of Congress, where the threshold for conviction is two thirds, which means 67 votes. On the one hand, it might be a stretch to think that 11 Republican senators could defect from their party. On the other hand, Trump is a lame duck, and doesn’t have the power and influence he has had, and there have been signs that some Republicans senators think he has been a disaster. But 11 out of 44— a full quarter of all GOP members—- sounds out of reach.

Even Trump himself has opined on it: he told a campaign rally, “I’ve become very good at beating them in impeachment.”

The other option people are talking about is the 25th Amendment, which says in Section 4, “Whenever the Vice President and a majority of either the principal officers of the executive departments or of such other body as Congress may by law provide, transmit to the President pro tempore of the Senate and the Speaker of the House of Representatives their written declaration that the President is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office, the Vice President shall immediately assume the powers and duties of the office as Acting President.”

In short, if a majority of a presidential cabinet including the vice president decide a president is unfit to serve, they can remove him. But looking at the cast of characters, and considering the chaos they know that would cause, the common conclusion to come to is, fat chance.

Leave a comment

Back in October, NBC News polled Americans on whether a Democratic House should impeach the president. 52% said yes. The question is, would it be productive, or counterproductive?

Abraham Lincoln might have had an answer.

After the North defeated the South in the Civil War, Lincoln could have held trials for the southerners’ treason. But instead, he instructed General Ulysses S. Grant to be lenient with them so the nation could rebuild. So Grant told them to disarm, then to “go home and do their spring planting.” Because of that, there was no post-war guerrilla warfare, no wave of terrorism against the North.

So I suppose if Abraham Lincoln were to weigh in on the merits of impeaching Donald Trump, he would say counterproductive. But he would have to convince an awful lot of Americans to abandon the countervailing urge to demand accountability for this man who has hurt America so much.



 

© 2026 Greg Dobbs



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.