[Salon] Impeachment or Not, Hegseth Has to Go



https://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/hegseth-impeachment-massie-democratic-congress/?share-code=EF9otQLxDgAW&_bhlid=3f53b311e06ca5420b8bdc4dcb9404e3e5f77a6a

Impeachment or Not, Hegseth Has to Go

Impeachment or Not, Hegseth Has to GoDefense Secretary Pete Hegseth speaks during a press conference at the Pentagon in Washington, Nov. 10, 2026. (AP Photo by Nathan Howard)
Player Image
World Politics Review
Impeachment or Not, Hegseth Has to Go
8 min

Once the new Democratic-controlled Congress is seated in January, expect more of the three “big i’s” of Congressional oversight: impeachments, indictments and investigations.

The first of these started before all the votes from last week’s midterms were even tallied. On Monday, outgoing Republican Rep. Thomas Massie introduced articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. That effort ultimately failed when Massie’s Republican colleagues, who still have a majority in the House, closed ranks to kill the effort. But Democratic lawmakers are likely to take it up again next year.

Setting aside whether Hegseth was ever qualified to be Secretary of Defense, his time in the role has been an unmitigated disaster. He has made a host of decisions ranging from questionable to unconscionable.

He wasted senior military officers’ time by calling all of them to a meeting at Quantico about grooming and fitness standards that could have easily been an email.  He has purged the officer ranks of qualified individuals by disproportionately halting the promotions of women and minorities. He’s obsessed with the testosterone levels of military personnel, rather than ensuring that they have adequate food while deployed. He thinks graduate education for military officers should simply extend training on battlefield tactics, completely missing that senior officers require a “macro view” of warfare.

The list goes on. His obsession with “lethality” underpinned his announcement to make public the execution of Nidal Malik Hasan, the convicted gunman in the 2009 Fort Hood mass shooting, before President Donald Trump shut down that plan. He has overseen a campaign of lethal airstrikes on alleged drug-smuggling boats in the Caribbean and Eastern Pacific, which has done nothing to actually curb the flow of drugs into the United States and has likely killed scores of innocent civilians. He shared war plans over a Signal group chat. And his glorification of violence made him one of the most vocal advocates in Trump’s Cabinet for initiating the ill-conceived war against Iran.

This is not even a complete accounting of Hegseth’s misdeeds, which makes it shocking to recall that he’s been in the role for less than two years. But impeachment isn’t about being bad at your job. It’s about breaking the law. And that is where Massie focused his impeachment filing.

Specifically, the articles of impeachment focused on a slew of actions Hegseth took without congressional authorization, including the war against Iran, the boat-bombing campaign in the Caribbean and Eastern Pacific, and the kidnapping of a foreign leader, Venezuela’s Nicolas Maduro.

But beyond the legal case against Hegseth, there is another reason he is unfit to serve as Secretary of Defense: He has harmed the U.S. military.

To understand why, it’s important to understand America’s long tradition of venerating and even glorifying its Armed Forces—for better or for worse. This is visible in nearly every aspect of society. Military service members often take center stage during cultural and sporting events. The exploits of military personnel, particularly those among the special operations forces, are featured in bestselling novels and blockbuster movies. For many high school and university students, enlisting in the military or joining the Reserve Officers’ Training Corps is a rite of passage.


The problem is that Hegseth’s worldview misunderstands the role of the Armed Forces, both as an instrument of policy and as an instrument of warfare.


Some observers have argued this tradition goes too far. The feminist international relations theorist Cynthia Enloe, for example, has written critically of the ways in which America’s highly militarized society—particularly after 9/11—works to the detriment of women.

Hegseth’s approach to being Secretary of Defense, including renaming the agency he leads as the “Department of War,” again without the congressional authorization required by law, plays to a caricature built from America’s obsession with its military. He is obsessed with the concept of lethality.

Some might condone this, given that the U.S. must navigate a dangerous world. After all, why shouldn’t maximum lethality be the focus of the military?

The problem is that Hegseth’s worldview misunderstands the role of the Armed Forces, both as an instrument of policy and as an instrument of warfare. The military should be the last resort in resolving disputes, and it should be used judiciously. Ideally, the military would be able to complete its job without firing a shot, and even when shots are fired, it should be done with purpose.

Take the Iran war. Hegseth was never able to articulate a coherent reason why all diplomatic avenues had been exhausted and so many lives—those of U.S. service members as well as people in Iran and around the region—had to be put at risk.

Even when it comes to warfighting, Hegseth seems unwilling or unable to understand how it’s actually done. The reality of modern warfare is that it’s all about logistics: ensuring that troops are adequately fed, clothed and supplied. This is why military officers are so fond of quoting the maxim, often apocryphally attributed to Gen. Omar Bradley, that “amateurs talk tactics, professionals talk logistics.” Yet Hegseth has been obsessed with the tactical, aesthetic and physical fitness elements of the Armed Forces, while downplaying the less glamorous but arguably more important aspects of military operations.

Hegseth’s misguided leadership has had negative impacts on U.S. troops. The aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln was chronically undersupplied during the Iran war, causing morale on the ship to plunge to dangerous levels. Hegseth also failed to account for U.S. missile stockpiles before entering a missile-intensive war.

For all of Hegseth’s emphasis on warfighting, he himself seems to have never read the central text on the subject: Carl von Clausewitz’s “On War.” The celebrated 19th-century Prussian general famously observed that war is a political act, “a continuation of State policy by other means.” In more concrete terms, the use of violent force against an adversary will amount to little if that adversary has no incentive to give in or agree to a political settlement. For Hegseth, the military campaign is the only thing that matters, not the ultimate objective of waging war: an advantageous outcome in its aftermath.

Ultimately, impeachment or not, Hegseth needs to go. He’s not just bad at his job—he is weakening a key pillar of America’s privileged position on the world stage: the smart use of military power. Simply put, the U.S. military deserves better.

Paul Poast is an associate professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of Chicago and a nonresident fellow at the Chicago Council on Global Affairs.




This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.