Ukraine’s Collapse Will Be Sudden and Catastrophic — and Europe Is Still Acting Like It’s WinningA conversation with Michael von der Schulenburg MEP
Michael von der Schulenburg, A veteran German diplomat and MEP and Former Assistant Secretary General at the UN, warns that the Ukraine war is already decided on the battlefield. Ukraine is close to breaking, and Europe’s refusal to face reality will make the final stage far more costly for everyone. The war decides the diplomacy Von der Schulenburg has spent decades in war zones and peace negotiations for the United Nations. In a recent conversation he argued that diplomacy does not shape wars — wars shape diplomacy. Right now Russia dominates both the land and the air war. Ukraine is close to a collapse that will not be gradual. In his experience, these things break suddenly. He pointed to the destruction of bridges over the Dnipro, the loss of port access through Odesa, the steady degradation of energy and transport infrastructure, and the growing role of irregular forces. These are classic signs of a state losing central control. At the same time Ukraine’s population has fallen dramatically since independence. A country that once had over 50 million people now has roughly half that number, with a large share dependent on social support. Europe is still talking like the winner While the military situation has shifted, European governments continue to act as if they hold the stronger hand. In recent meetings they have insisted on maximalist conditions — full Russian withdrawal, reparations, and war-crimes trials — that no longer match what is happening on the ground. Von der Schulenburg described the European approach in Dublin as still behaving “as if we are the winners.” He noted that large groups of European representatives cannot negotiate effectively. They block each other, repeat the same demands, and have little room to compromise. Meanwhile the real discussions involving the United States and Russia have largely left the Europeans on the outside. This exclusion, he argued, is not an accident. It follows from the military balance. A failed state will cost Europe more Von der Schulenburg was blunt about the consequences of letting the war continue until Ukraine collapses. A broken Ukrainian state will not simply disappear. It will produce more refugees, more weapons in circulation, and long-term reconstruction costs that Europe will largely have to carry. He stressed that Europe’s interest in Ukraine has been mainly in fighting Russia, not in the long-term viability of the Ukrainian state itself. Once the fighting stops, that interest will fade — but the costs will not. He also criticised the broader European strategy. Sanctions have hurt European economies more than they have stopped Russian ones. Opportunities to negotiate earlier were repeatedly rejected. Now Europe occupies a weaker position and still refuses to adjust. The result, in his view, is an irrational policy that increases the risk of escalation while reducing Europe’s influence. What needs to change The only realistic way to limit the damage, von der Schulenburg said, is for Europe to talk directly to Russia about ending the war in a way that preserves Ukraine as a functioning state. Continuing to tell Ukraine to fight on while ignoring the military facts will not change the outcome. It will only make the final phase bloodier and more expensive. Collapse, he repeated, is usually sudden. The longer Europe pretends otherwise, the less leverage it will have when the moment arrives. You can watch the full interview with Michael von der Schulenburg here: Wherever you are in the world, whatever your nationality and religion, I wish you much peace. You're currently a free subscriber to The Peacemonger. For the full experience, upgrade your subscription. © 2026 ian |