Before the GCC sends Iran another invoice, it should recall the “either side” doctrine it so successfully pressed against Baghdad.
When Iraq invaded Kuwait in 1990, the Persian Gulf Arab states insisted on a principle few have challenged since: the aggressor pays. Security Council Resolution 687 held Iraq liable for “any direct loss, damage … or injury” resulting from its unlawful invasion. The UN Compensation Commission subsequently awarded $52.4 billion to some 1.5 million claimants.
The crucial detail lies in the Commission’s Decision 7. It deemed compensable any loss resulting from “military operations or threat of military action by either side.” Iraq therefore paid for what its own troops destroyed and for damage caused by the coalition’s bombing of Kuwait, because the defenders’ military operations were a direct consequence of Iraq’s aggression. Saudi Arabia itself invoked the “either side” formula before the Commission to recover losses arising from coalition operations launched from its territory.
The Arab states now argue the opposite. They demand that Iran, the state attacked on 28 February 2026, pay for its defensive response, while those who launched the war escape the bill. Why was the aggressor held liable for the defender’s bombs in 1991, while in 2026 the defender is expected to pay for its own? Why did “either side” lead to the aggressor then, but to the victim now?
Applied consistently, the precedent established by Decision 7 leaves the host states with no claim whatsoever. They are not bystanders caught between two belligerents. Under Article 3(f) of UN General Assembly Resolution 3314, a state that places its territory at the disposal of an aggressor for an act of aggression commits aggression itself. A state that allows its ports and airfields to serve as operational bases also forfeits its neutrality under the 1907 Hague Conventions (Convention V, Article 5; Convention XIII, Article 5). These host states are co-belligerents. In 1991, Iraq received no compensation for coalition strikes on its own territory because an aggressor cannot claim reparation for the consequences of its own aggression. The same principle applies to those who join the aggression. Iran is the injured state. Under the Chorzów Factory judgment and Articles 31 and 47 of the Articles on State Responsibility, it is entitled to full reparation from the United States and every state that made its territory available for the aggression.
In 1991, the Persian Gulf Arab states asked the world to trace the damage back to the aggression. Iran is asking for precisely the same.