[Salon] Bureau of Bureau of Industry and Security issues new rules about chip exports to foreign data centers



https://www.linkedin.com/posts/christopher-padilla-48350a181_this-press-release-from-commerces-bureau-share-7528105692533170176-SlVm/

Christopher Padilla’s Post

This press release from Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security is simply extraordinary. In the first line, Commerce says new rules being published Monday to crack down on AI chips going to foreign data centers were "written by and at the direction of the Department of the Treasury and the National Security Council." 😳 In 35 years of working on export controls, I've never seen anything like this: BIS issuing a rule (which only it has the legal authority to do) that it claims other agencies wrote, or demanded it write, clearly over the objections of Commerce. Leave aside that this is a closing-the-barn-door-too late situation, following reports that billions in AI chips have already been diverted to China. What's striking is the open attempt by Commerce to avoid responsibility for publishing this rule. The regulation, which takes immediate effect, is more than 130 pages long and is signed by Commerce Under Secretary Kessler. It was very clearly written by BIS. Neither Treasury nor the NSC has the technical or regulatory expertise (or legal authority) to write on their own such a complex rule amending Commerce's Export Administration Regulations. So why this line in the press release? Shifting blame, clearly. Seemingly refusing, even after all that has come to light, to crack down on AI chip exports going to foreign data centers and instead passing the buck to Treasury and the White House. It suggests complete breakdown of interagency cooperation on export controls, with Cabinet officials publicly pointing fingers at one another. Never seen anything like it.

27 Comments

My bet is China will outdesign American top end chips in the next 3 months. And good on 'em! 👏

Thanks for bringing attention to this, Chris. I remember a time in which government leaders took responsibility for the areas under their authority--and invited partnership and oversight to ensure they were working collaboratively and considering all the angles. Clearly those days are gone.

After 17 years at DoD trying to stop Commerce from approving specific advanced technology exports to China, I have seen Commerce closely and intimately in action through 4 administrations. Every several years Commerce gets forced to say "oops, we need to do something about China", write some "fierce" new rule and then immediately design ways to get around the rule and SELL the technology anyway. DoD/DoW is responsible for the national security position on these exports, but has no teeth, steps out of the way and allows it to happen. The US has taught and enabled China's behavior at almost every turn and China's navigates our system at the expert level; if they can't get it from us they get it from other countries to whom we have sold it. This doesn't get fixed by the department who has caused a decades-long mess. Money (commerce) rules; national security is somewhere at the back of the pack with human rights and counterfeit purses.

Alternative theory: It was written by AI and not properly scrubbed prior to release.

You gotta hand it to the spooks running the chips strategy for the U.S. This is their baby, and they have stuck with it through thick and thin lol. For anyone who gives a shit about my thoughts on this, I am writing a series on this entire farce: https://evanwrowe.substack.com/p/a-cartel-by-any-other-name-part-1 part 2 will be out tomorrow. I will say, I would not entirely count the U.S. strategy out, as it fits within a tactical framework of really trying to capitalize on the 2027 period as essential in racing ahead--racing to where? who knows. And China for its part, has played what i've been calling the 'second mover advantage' in my upcoming book.. which is lagging because I keep substacking the news cycle lol.

While the press release and its tone appear unprecedented, I have long experience with BIS revealing an eagerness to deflect responsibility for its decisions. This extraordinary line takes the existing pattern to a new level.

When the ship is going down, the captain either stays on board and if necessary drowns to save room for passengers on the lifeboats and takes responsibility for hitting the obstacle (the Titanic) or flees with his or her significant other while passengers are left behind to drown while taking no responsibility for running the ship into the obstacle (the Costa Concordia).

Complete breakdown of governing discipline.

Outsourcing of rule making will not end well.

Hi Ken "wheres the bottom?



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.