[Salon] The Ghost of Ramsay MacDonald: Burnham Takes Britain Back to 1945 — and Then to 1931



The Ghost of Ramsay MacDonald: Burnham Takes Britain Back to 1945 — and Then to 1931

After the 1931 collapse of the Labour government, led by Prime Minister Ramsey MacDonald, British journalist Malcolm Muggeridge wrote: “One sees MacDonald as a victim of history rather than a shaper of it; a Scottish loon who found himself on the captain's deck of a sinking ship ... so furious a storm, so wild a gale, so fierce a whirlwind, and such featherweight men and work.” Many analysts believe the same will soon be said of Andy Burnham

Let there be no mistake: Former Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham already looks set to be Britain’s most important prime minister since Boris Johnson — and possibly its longest-serving one since David Cameron. After only three months in office, as I write, he is off to a strong, confident and dynamic start that is more decisive than any British leader since Tony Blair, or even Margaret Thatcher herself.

However, while many of Burnham’s initiatives are highly popular or just plain necessary, others have been erratic. Above all looming in the background like the Spectral Ghost of Hamlet’s father in Shakespeare’s eponymous play, or Charles Dickens’s Terrifying Ghost of Christmas Future, hangs the ghastly spectral image of Ramsay MacDonald, the Boneless Wonder himself (as Winston Churchill called him) and the collapse of the Labour government of 1931.

Burnham is no ridiculous blustering blowhard, farcical Harold Wilson in the 1960s, or some joyless, hapless Eeyore donkey figure from A.A. Milne’s much loved Christopher Robin stories. That was the image — and the fate — of doomed British Prime Minister Theresa May who trudged haplessly and joylessly through the job for three dull and despairing years from 2016 to 2019. And he contrasts most favorably with Keir Starmer, the self-satisfied, sleepwalking inept clown, serenely oblivious to his own ineptitude, whom Burnham replaced in July this year.

Starmer was a theoretical lawyer conspicuous before his rise for his extreme passivity — some might call it contemptible cowardice — in refusing to take any national legal action against the shocking pandemic of racist grooming gangs that have been raping and enslaving tens of thousands of impoverished girls in destitute, former industrial towns across the Midlands and the North of England for decades. Starmer’s shocking passivity seamlessly continued during his own two woeful years clinging to the shadows of power in Whitehall.

By contrast, Burnham has been a whirlwind of activity and new policy initiatives: Britain has seen nothing like it since Thatcher’s or Wilson’s days. Already, Burnham has boldly bitten the hard-as-iron indigestible bullet at the heart of Britain’s latest collapse over the past decade: He has recognized the total failure of the fraudulent efforts to establish a new trade, financial and economic basis for Britain since Brexit, the British exit from the European Union, voted for by a narrow margin in a national referendum in 2015, but only implemented — and disastrously so — by Boris Johnson by the end of 2020.

Less than seven years later, Burnham’s government has announced it will seek reentry to Europe.

The dynamic new prime minister is even exploring initiatives to try and revive British industry. And he has shown signs of at least sidelining some of the insanely destructive and green environmentalist and anti-energy production policies that have collapsed Britain’s living standards so woefully over the past generation

Any adequate analysis of what this would mean for Britain is too massive to be given justice here. But the move is enormously popular with Britain’s financial community and what is left of its industrial, production and agricultural sectors. Younger Britons in the south and east of the country, who voted overwhelmingly to remain in the EU in the 2015 referendum, are even more unanimous to return to it. Far from ending Third World mass immigration as was promised, Brexit has only seen it soar out of control more than ever.

Also, Brussels’s huge bureaucracy and killer record on stifling economic growth and free enterprise hold far fewer terrors now. That is because in the past 11 years since the Brexit vote and the nearly seven years since full withdrawal, Britain’s own record in these areas has been even more woeful than the EU’s. To have any hope of recovery and survival, British’s industries and agriculture must regain full unfettered access to the great continental Europe market and to the crucial resource of its highly mobile, hard-working immigrant laborers from Poland, Slovakia and Romania. British agriculture and its construction industry have never recovered from the loss of free access to them.

However, returning Britain into the EU is only one strand of Burnham’s ambitious new initiatives. He has promised popular measures to end Britain’s homelessness problem. He has pledged to cap public transportation costs for the elderly and the destitute and to pour yet more resources into Britain’s woefully inadequate but still revered, over-bureaucratized and creaking National Health Service.

The dynamic new prime minister is even exploring initiatives to try and revive British industry. And he has shown signs of at least sidelining some of the insanely destructive and green environmentalist and anti-energy production policies that have collapsed Britain’s living standards so woefully over the past generation.

Britain’s finance minister, or chancellor of the exchequer John Healey has already announced plans to impose punitive taxation on the major financial institutions of the City of London, Britain’s last and greatest source of major income. And he is also looking to impose punitive taxation and wealth grabs on inherited wealth, the super rich and even modestly sized, family-owned businesses. All of this points to a degree of imposed socialism, state control and regulation of the economy far beyond anything New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani or likely 2028 Democratic presidential candidate Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez dream of inflicting on the United States. Such prosperity-eroding and misery-generating policies, of course, will be enthusiastically welcomed by the wealth-killing, repressive EU bureaucrats in Brussels.

Already, before any of these visionary plans have even started their ponderous legislative progress through the House of Commons, now de facto the only real chamber of Britain’s parliament, the dark clouds of harsh global economic reality are casting their dark shadows over Burnham’s grand dreams. For all these ambitious visions of the New Jerusalem, so dreamed of and sung about by the British Labour movement over the past 120 years, already face the same enormous looming iceberg of cold reality that stymied similar dreams of Clement Atlee’s Labour governments from 1945 to 1951 and Harold Wilson’s starting in 1964 and ending in 1976. Britain cannot afford any of them, and the international financial markets will not finance them.

As Matt Oliver pointed out in the London Daily Telegraph on October 4, Britain no longer even has the remaining base to stage the kind of modest industrial production revival it enjoyed under Margaret Thatcher, John Major, Tony Blair and David Cameron from the mid-1980s to around 2015. “As a share of Britain’s economic output, manufacturing has been in decline for decades, having gone from accounting for 30 percent of all jobs in the 1970s to less than 8 percent today,” he wrote.

Since Labour took over from the discredited Conservatives in 2024, under Starmer and now Burnham, things have gotten even worse, Oliver continued. “Increases to national insurance contributions, more onerous employment laws and carbon taxes on energy consumption are just a few of the things that have pushed up costs for businesses. This is why Make UK, the manufacturers’ body, has warned that factories face an ‘existential threat,’” he wrote.

Already, as major news services have reported, a global and domestic bond sell-off drove the 30-year British government gilt yield briefly above 6 percent in October 2026, its highest level in more than 28 years. According to analyst Andrew Craig, on his popular Plain English Finance podcast on October 19, the key forces driving this crisis are high inflation, escalating energy and public service costs, the soaring British national debt — now up to 100 percent of GDP — and concerns over the Burnham government’s high taxation and redistributive financial policies, as well as political uncertainty surrounding the government’s fiscal headroom and upcoming budget.

Craig also cautioned that the Burnham government’s anticipated financial cushion to support its spending plans has already shriveled by two-thirds from a projected at £24 billion, or $31.93 billion, in March to as low as an estimated £8.5 billion, or $11.31 billion, today because of soaring borrowing costs on international markets. Chancellor of the Exchequer Healey knows he will have to soothe the fears of investors in those global markets when he presents his first annual budget to the House of Commons on October 28. (Like so much else in British parliamentary democracy and government, the revered annual budgetary ritual is a remnant of ancient times created by Sir Robert Walpole, Britain’s first real prime minister, in 1733.)

The Institute for Fiscal Studies in London, one of Britain’s most respected independent financial analytical centers, on October 12, warned in a study of the challenges and dangers that Healey faces. In the study, the respected Moyeen Islam warned: “John Healey will be delivering his first Budget against a backdrop of persistent inflation and rising bond yields across the world.” Indeed, he continued, “The UK (United Kingdom) government faces much higher borrowing costs than many similar nations. UK government debt stands at around 90 percent of national income, and the share of national income needed to service that debt (nearly 4 percent) is now twice as high as it was in the 10 years preceding the COVID-19 pandemic. The upcoming OBR (Britain’s official Office for Budget Responsibility) forecast will revise up the debt interest bill, which, in the March forecast, was already due to reach £137 billion ($182.28 billion) in 2030–31.”

Islam therefore concluded: “Given these factors, maintaining the confidence of a wary bond market will be a key consideration for the Chancellor in a few weeks’ time. An adverse market reaction to the Budget would once again draw attention to the UK’s ongoing fiscal vulnerability and could overshadow the more substantive debate of policy measures in the Budget.”

Islam’s succinct and trenchant analysis eerily echoes the relentless global financial realities that destroyed the reforming New Jerusalem dreams of Britain’s first Labour Party prime minister, Ramsay MacDonald, almost a century ago.

In his classic autobiography, “Chronicles of Wasted Time,” legendary British journalist Malcolm Muggeridge described how Labour government Colonial Secretary Lord Passfield, previously known as Sidney Webb, recalled to him how MacDonald and his Cabinet ministers learned that the New York banks would not lend them any more money to keep the British financial system afloat during the great global financial crisis of 1931. “In his soft, sibilant voice he described how he and the other Cabinet ministers at 10 Downing Street on that warm August evening waiting for a telephone call from New York to tell them whether American banking houses were prepared to put up a loan sufficient to enable the (British) Treasury to go on supporting the pound on the Gold Standard. When the answer came as no, there was nothing more they could do.”

Muggeridge continued: “To me it seemed … to mark the end of any notion that the Labour Party, or any Social Democratic party similarly constituted, can be an effective institute of fundamental social change.” Instead, Muggeridge concluded, “one sees MacDonald as a victim of history rather than a shaper of it; a Scottish loon who found himself on the captain’s deck of a sinking ship … so furious a storm, so wild a gale, so fierce a whirlwind, and such featherweight men and work.”

So will it be said of Andy Burnham.

Writer, Journalist, Political Analyst

Martin Sieff



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.